Who got the better deal: Yankees without Soto or Mets with him?

Follow Us

Better off? Measuring the Yankees without Soto against Mets’ new reality

New York baseball’s defining storyline transcends typical victory tallies and seasonal achievements — it encompasses franchise direction, long-term financial strategy, and the gravitational pull of one transcendent talent: Juan Soto.

During winter’s most dramatic roster reshuffling, the New York Mets secured Soto through an astronomical 15-year, $765 million agreement, extracting the four-time All-Star from Yankees pinstripes in a crosstown heist that shook baseball’s foundation. The Bronx experienced collective devastation watching Soto depart after propelling them toward 2024’s AL championship. His singular Yankees campaign produced remarkable statistics: .288/.419/.569, 41 homers, 109 RBIs during regular play, while his postseason excellence (.327/.469/.633) amplified the departure pain for a fanbase that had already embraced him as their own.

Nevertheless, approaching mid-May 2025, the anticipated narrative has reversed dramatically: Yankees appear stronger without Soto, at least presently.

Yankees flourish with strategic balance and Judge; Soto not missed

Following Soto’s rejection of the Yankees’ substantial extension proposal in favor of Queens’ opportunity, numerous analysts predicted a significant Bronx offensive decline. The conventional wisdom suggested that losing a generational talent would cripple any lineup. Instead, the Yankees accelerated their performance, benefiting from calculated acquisitions, unexpected breakouts, and Aaron Judge’s relentless excellence that has reached new heights without sharing the spotlight.

Their offense dominates Major League Baseball entirely across batting average (.263), home runs (76), and OPS (.828). These statistics tell only part of the story. Yankees’ 5.81 runs per game represent a considerable improvement over 2024’s 5.03, indicating comprehensive offensive enhancement that extends beyond individual performances to reflect superior lineup construction and strategic depth.

Jon Heyman captured the prevailing sentiment succinctly in his latest column:

“No Soto, no problem.”

Judge, the defending AL MVP, constructs another legendary campaign that may surpass his previous achievements. After 39 contests, he paces all of baseball with a staggering .412 average, 41 homers, and 37 RBIs. His trajectory suggests not just third MVP consideration, but potentially one of the greatest offensive seasons in modern history. Meanwhile, the supporting cast prevents opposing pitchers from exploiting lineup protection vacuums that Soto’s departure theoretically created.

Notable contributors elevating the Yankees include:

Paul Goldschmidt

• Batting Average (AVG): .346
• On-Base Percentage (OBP): .417
• Slugging Percentage (SLG): .471
• Home Runs (HR): 5
• Runs Batted In (RBI): 22
• On-Base Plus Slugging (OPS): .902

Goldschmidt continues to provide clutch production and leadership, stabilizing the infield while mentoring younger players.

Trent Grisham

• Batting Average (AVG): .283
• On-Base Percentage (OBP): .367
• Slugging Percentage (SLG): .628
• Home Runs (HR): 12
• Runs Batted In (RBI): 22
• On-Base Plus Slugging (OPS): .996

Grisham has evolved into an everyday offensive threat, earning regular starts through consistent production.

Ben Rice

• Batting Average (AVG): .254
• On-Base Percentage (OBP): .355
• Slugging Percentage (SLG): .545
• Home Runs (HR): 9
• Runs Batted In (RBI): 20
• On-Base Plus Slugging (OPS): .900

The rookie sensation exceeds all expectations, filling gaps created by veteran injuries with remarkable poise.

Cody Bellinger

• Batting Average (AVG): .229
• On-Base Percentage (OBP): .305
• Slugging Percentage (SLG): .383
• Home Runs (HR): 5
• Runs Batted In (RBI): 21
• On-Base Plus Slugging (OPS): .688

Bellinger demonstrates exceptional defensive versatility alongside steady offensive contributions, even if his power numbers haven’t fully materialized yet.

“The growth in our young guys is going to be the key to us getting back to the World Series,” Judge stated during a recent media session. “Anytime you add Paul Goldschmidt and Cody Bellinger into the mix… good things are going to happen.”

While managing significant injuries affecting Gerrit Cole, Luis Gil, Giancarlo Stanton, DJ LeMahieu, plus key relievers Jonathan Loáisiga and Jake Cousins, the Yankees maintain an impressive 22-17 record, positioning them atop the AL East. Their offensive resilience particularly counters early-season skepticism about post-Soto viability.

Mets success but not through Soto

Meanwhile, in Queens, the organization celebrates a remarkable 25-15 start, claiming the National League’s premier record. However, Juan Soto, representing their historic $765 million centerpiece investment, hasn’t spearheaded these early achievements as anticipated.

In his first season with the Mets, Soto is batting .255 with 8 home runs, 20 RBIs, and an OPS of .845 over 43 games. While these numbers are solid, they fall short of the expectations set by his record-breaking contract. However, Soto has shown signs of improvement recently, posting a 1.077 OPS over his last 12 games. These numbers particularly disappoint when compared to his Yankees tenure, where similar sample sizes yielded significantly superior results.

Conversely, his teammate Pete Alonso is hitting .311 with 9 home runs, 36 RBIs, and an OPS of 1.004. Francisco Lindor is batting .297 with 9 home runs, 26 RBIs, and an OPS of .855.

Nevertheless, owner Steve Cohen maintains an unwavering perspective regarding his investment.

“I’m not worried about Juan. He’s totally focused on baseball. He’s a pure hitter. We’ll talk about it at the end of the year,” Cohen expressed during an extended conversation with SNY’s Danny Abriano.

Such patience demonstrates both wisdom and necessity. Soto historically experiences gradual seasonal starts before heating up dramatically. During 2024’s initial 19 games — despite batting with Judge’s protection — he registered a concerning .193 average and .710 OPS before ultimately finishing among baseball’s elite performers.

However, New York markets demand immediate returns on investment. Soto’s unprecedented contract creates heightened expectations where anything beneath MVP-caliber performance generates intense scrutiny, particularly given the Yankees’ current prosperity without him.

Evaluating economic efficiency and organizational impact

Soto’s agreement: 15 years, $765 million ($51 million annually) 

Judge’s compensation: 9 years, $360 million ($40 million annually)

Currently, Judge significantly outperforms Soto while costing approximately 80% annually. This financial efficiency becomes more pronounced when considering additional factors. The emergence of affordable talents like Rice and Grisham strengthens the Yankees’ strategic pivot — redistributing Soto-allocated resources toward proven performers like Max Fried (5-0, 1.19 ERA) and essential organizational depth — appearing increasingly shrewd with each passing week.

Despite Soto’s undeniable abilities and proven playoff excellence, the Mets haven’t yet activated the premium version, justifying their historic investment magnitude.

Yankees better off without Soto’s huge contract burden

While the Mets captured offseason headlines securing baseball’s brightest available name, the Yankees quietly constructed superior roster architecture, delivering tangible early-season results. Rather than collapsing post-Soto, they transformed strategically, proving that organizational depth matters more than individual stardom.

However, premature conclusions remain dangerous in baseball’s marathon season. 2025’s postseason represents the ultimate validation stage. Should Soto ignite during summer months and carry the Mets through October excellence, narratives shift instantly. Conversely, continued Judge-led Yankees domination returning toward championship contention maintains Bronx baseball supremacy.

One certainty emerges from early returns: The Yankees didn’t merely survive Juan Soto’s departure. They innovated systematically, potentially triumphing through calculated adaptation rather than emotional reaction.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us