Twist in tussle over Giuliani’s Yankees rings as son enters legal drama

Follow Us

The four Yankees World Series rings owned by former New York City mayor Rudy Giuliani have become a focal point in his mounting legal troubles. The iconic memorabilia, commemorating championships won during Giuliani’s tenure as mayor, now faces potential forfeiture as part of a $148 million defamation judgment against him in a defamation case.

This dispute arises from an award against Giuliani to two Georgia election workers, Ruby Freeman and Wandrea “Shaye” Moss, whom he falsely accused of ballot fraud during the 2020 presidential election. In an effort to collect the substantial judgment, the duo have sought the seizure of Giuliani’s assets, including the World Series rings.

Giuliani’s lawyer has stated that 90% of the required assets have already been turned over, including his Manhattan apartment, a vintage Mercedes once owned by Lauren Bacall, and other valuables. Yet, Giuliani and his legal team have fiercely resisted surrendering two key items: his Florida condo and the Yankees rings.

For Giuliani, the rings are more than jewelry—they symbolize a bygone era of personal and professional triumphs. But as his financial and legal woes deepen, their fate hangs in the balance, drawing attention to their monetary value, historical significance, and the controversy surrounding their acquisition.

The former NYC mayor claims to have gifted the rings to his son, Andrew Giuliani, in 2018. His son has now intervened, asserting that the rings belong to him, as they were a gift from his father. He has filed legal documents to prevent the rings from being used to satisfy the defamation award, stating that the rings hold significant sentimental value, symbolizing the bond he shares with his father over their mutual love for the Yankees.

Giuliani’s Yankees rings courted controversy earlier too

Giuliani’s rings represent the Yankees’ dominance during the late 1990s and early 2000s, an era when the team secured championships in 1996, 1998, 1999, and 2000. As mayor of New York, Giuliani was a fixture at Yankee Stadium, embodying the city’s resilience and passion for baseball, particularly in the wake of the September 11 attacks.

The ownership and acquisition of Giuliani’s World Series rings remain under scrutiny. Questions about when and how the former mayor obtained the jewelry could complicate legal proceedings.

A 2007 Village Voice investigation unearthed discrepancies in Giuliani’s account. It claimed that he purchased the rings after leaving office, with payments totaling $16,000 for all four—a figure far below their actual market value. However, sources suggested Giuliani may have received at least one ring while still in office, raising potential conflict-of-interest concerns.

New York law prohibits public officials from accepting gifts of substantial monetary value from entities conducting business with the city. Despite Giuliani’s denials, the Yankees did not offer similar purchases to non-team personnel during that championship run.

A worthy investment by Giuliani

While Giuliani listed the rings alongside other jewelry at a combined value of $30,000 in court documents, experts argue that the true worth is significantly higher. Ken Goldin, founder of Goldin Auctions, estimates their collective auction value at $200,000, citing Giuliani’s name recognition as a major factor in driving up prices.

Comparable rings have fetched high sums at auction. A 1996 Yankees championship ring, crafted in 10-karat gold by Balfour, is currently listed for $34,000. A 1999 ring, also by Balfour, was recently estimated at $26,000–$35,000 by Sotheby’s.

Championship rings in general have become coveted items in the collectibles market, often selling for tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars. For instance, a fraudulent New England Patriots Super Bowl LI ring sold for $337,000 in 2018, while team owner Robert Kraft’s authentic ring from the same season raised over $1 million at auction for COVID-19 relief.

In an October court filing, Giuliani’s son, Andrew, claimed that the rings had been gifted to him by his father in 2018 during a late-night family gathering. The assertion complicates the legal case, as the plaintiffs argue that the rings remain Giuliani’s property and should be part of the judgment.

Giuliani’s financial struggles have been well-documented, with the former mayor openly admitting his inability to meet legal expenses. “I can’t pay my bills,” he reportedly told a judge earlier this year.

Adding to his woes, Giuliani has sought multiple delays in his upcoming trial, set for January 16, to determine whether the rings and his Florida condo will be subject to seizure. So far, the court has denied these requests.

Giuliani and the Yankees: A legacy in jeopardy

For New Yorkers, Giuliani’s connection to the Yankees has long been a point of civic pride. A lifelong fan who grew up in Brooklyn, Giuliani’s public support of the Bronx Bombers became a defining feature of his mayoralty. He wore Yankees hats to public events, negotiated the construction of the new Yankee Stadium, and even sported a championship ring during his ill-fated 2008 presidential campaign.

The rings now stand as relics of Giuliani’s brighter days, a stark contrast to his current legal and financial turmoil. For the plaintiffs in the defamation case, however, the rings represent a tangible asset that could help close a massive financial gap.

The collectibles craze brings focus on Yankees rings

The debate over Giuliani’s Yankees rings also highlights the booming market for championship memorabilia. Modern championship rings, often adorned with diamonds and intricate designs, have become status symbols for players and collectors alike.

For example, the Kansas City Chiefs’ Super Bowl rings reportedly cost $40,000 each, with replicas offered to fans for a fraction of the price. Heritage Auctions recently sold replica Chiefs rings commemorating the 2019 and 2022 Super Bowl victories for over $80,000 apiece.

Even older rings from legends like Bill Russell, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, and Kobe Bryant have commanded high prices in recent years, fueling what some call a “bauble bubble” in sports memorabilia.

As Giuliani’s legal saga unfolds, the fate of his World Series rings remains uncertain. Will they be auctioned to help satisfy the judgment, or will the court rule in favor of his family’s claim?

Regardless of the outcome, the case serves as a reminder of how objects steeped in history and sentiment can become flashpoints in legal battles. For Giuliani, the rings are more than mementos—they’re a link to a storied past that feels increasingly out of reach.

For now, the rings’ story continues to captivate, blending legal drama, sports history, and the complexities of one man’s fall from grace. As the trial date approaches, the outcome could shape not only Giuliani’s future but also the legacy of these iconic symbols of the Yankees’ glory.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us