NASHVILLE — During Monday’s Winter Meetings, Yankees Assistant General Manager Michael Fishman found himself on the defensive while speaking with reporters. His candid admission stands in contrast to GM Brian Cashman’s tirade.
Fishman stressed the need for the Yankees to make substantial changes, but in a strategic and intelligent manner. He stated that the goal is to assemble the best possible roster. He underscored the importance of avoiding overreactions and hasty decisions made under pressure. Instead, the focus should be on making decisions that ultimately benefit the franchise.
The Yankees’ Annual Shareholders’ Meeting Addresses Criticism of the Team’s Analytical Approach
The General Shareholders’ Meeting expressed its understanding, stating that the company has set high standards that have not been met. It conveyed its commitment to continually strive for improvement.

Fishman navigated his responses with some difficulty, articulating his comments thoughtfully when addressing sensitive topics, such as the team’s collaboration with Zelus Analytics and the way statistical information is conveyed to the players. He went to great lengths to justify and defend a specific aspect of the organization that has recently been the subject of significant criticism.
When asked about his response to fans who have criticized the Yankees’ analytical approach, Fishman sent a clear and concise message. Simply expressing that sentiment won’t be enough to satisfy Yankees fans. Their expectations center on tangible results, especially after the disheartening and disastrous 2023 season. During that season, the Yankees fell just short of the playoffs, finishing just three losses away from their first losing season in three decades.
The decision to partner with Zelus during this offseason was driven by the goal of steering the club in the right direction, particularly with regard to how the Yankees interpret and use statistical data. Fishman clarified that this is not an audit; rather, the Yankees will maintain confidentiality by keeping all their records under lock and key during this evaluation, focusing solely on examining the data models provided by the external analytics firm.
Fishman stated that they would have access to whatever the external analytics firm had produced, emphasizing that the firm would not be granted access to their internal work. He explained that it would be up to his team to determine how to integrate the external work with their own, making decisions about when and how to use the information and implementing the necessary adjustments.
He noted that the process of implementing changes based on his findings will be a lengthy one. In some cases, it could take several months, potentially extending into the next offseason. This timeline could pose challenges, as the Yankees must make numerous adjustments this winter to position themselves for a postseason run in 2024. Owner Hal Steinbrenner had pledged to make “major changes” early in the offseason, going beyond mere player acquisitions.

The JGA Respects Criticism
Fishman acknowledged that they had not done a satisfactory job in the past, stating that there is always room for improvement. He expressed his belief that certain aspects could have been explained or taught more effectively.
The way the organization communicates its analyses differs from the perspective, opinions, and approach that Zelus will offer. Captain Aaron Judge was one of several prominent Yankees—both past and present—who criticized the methods used to convey statistical information to the team’s players.
Fishman assured that communication is an issue the Yankees are actively addressing. He has engaged in internal discussions with the players to understand their perspectives and collaboratively explore possible adjustments.
However, Fishman believes that the Yankees stand out for continually refining and adapting their analytical models, avoiding complacency despite any success they may have achieved. He also praised General Manager Brian Cashman for his ability to assemble a diverse inner circle, emphasizing how their varied backgrounds help foster a balanced approach across all facets of the organization.
During last month’s GM meetings, Cashman vocally supported the analytics department in a media session marked by strong language. Fishman conveyed that Cashman recognizes the efforts of the analytics department. According to him, Cashman understands that the analytics department has generated a wealth of valuable information, tools, and recommendations over the years.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.















