Judge leads Yankees comeback, but it’s bullpen that delivers redemption
Table of Contents
Follow UsNEW YORK — The Yankees bullpen rescued a season teetering on the edge Tuesday night.
Carlos Rodon’s outing went wrong in a hurry, and by the third inning, the Blue Jays had built a 6-1 lead that silenced Yankee Stadium. But five relievers stepped in and did what their starter could not — throw strikes, get outs, and restore order while sealing the Yankees’ 9-6 win.
The group of Fernando Cruz, Camilo Doval, Tim Hill, Devin Williams, and David Bednar combined for 6⅔ scoreless innings, allowing just three hits and no walks. They struck out nine, holding Toronto hitless after the fourth inning.
For a bullpen that had been battered in the first two games of the series, this performance wasn’t just impressive — it was redemption. The arms that stood tall when everything was on the line.
A disastrous start forces early action
Carlos Rodon never found his rhythm. His pitches missed spots, his fastball command wavered, and the Blue Jays jumped on him immediately. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. homered, Davis Schneider scored on a defensive miscue, and by the time Rodon left with one out in the third, he had allowed six runs on seven hits.
The Yankees season was hanging by a thread. The bullpen had to get the final 20 outs — or watch the team’s postseason collapse at home.
“We all knew what was at stake,” Fernando Cruz said later. “We weren’t letting the season end that way.”
Cruz stops the Yankees bleeding
Fernando Cruz entered with runners on base and the crowd uneasy. The right-hander worked quickly, retiring two batters to end the threat. His breaking ball had bite, and his command was sharp.
“Stop the bleeding,” Cruz said simply. “We attacked them and let our guys do the job.”
That quick shutdown gave the Yankees dugout a spark. The momentum began to tilt — and the bullpen refused to give it back.
Doval and Hill keep Toronto in check
Camilo Doval took over in the fourth and used his high-velocity sinker to neutralize Toronto’s right-handed bats. He induced weak contact, forcing groundouts and eating innings without drama.
Tim Hill followed with one of the most crucial moments of the night. With a runner on and one out, he faced Addison Barger and struck him out with a sweeping slider. The crowd roared as Hill walked off the mound, pumping his fist.
“He gave us energy,” Aaron Boone said. “Every guy who came in did their job and handed it off to the next. That’s exactly how you draw it up.”
Judge turns the tide, Chisholm completes comeback
The offense needed a spark, and Aaron Judge delivered it. In the fourth inning, with two runners aboard and the Yankees trailing 6-3, Judge stepped up against reliever Louis Varland.
The shot tied the game and set off a thunderous roar from the 47,399 fans at Yankee Stadium.
One inning later, Jazz Chisholm Jr. turned the rally into a lead. With one out in the fifth, Chisholm faced Varland and drilled a 99.4 mph fastball 409 feet into the right-center field seats.
The solo home run gave the Yankees a 7-6 lead and erased every trace of Rodon’s disastrous start.
From that point on, the bullpen took over, and the Blue Jays couldn’t recover.
Williams stretches out under pressure
Devin Williams, usually a one-inning arm, was called on for multiple frames. He responded with dominance. His changeup danced out of the zone, and the Blue Jays couldn’t square him up.
“It’s all hands on deck right now,” Williams said afterward. “You go until they tell you you’re done. Everyone was locked in.”
Williams worked through the sixth and part of the seventh before handing the ball to closer David Bednar. By then, the Yankees bullpen had done more than just keep the game close — they had completely flipped its tone.
Bednar slams the door
David Bednar’s first postseason appearance came with enormous pressure. The Blue Jays still had the heart of their order waiting, and any mistake could have reopened the door. But Bednar showed no nerves.
He struck out George Springer on a splitter, got Nathan Lukes looking, then induced a routine grounder from Guerrero Jr. to third to end the game. Yankee Stadium erupted as Bednar walked off calmly, his teammates greeting him at the dugout steps.
“You want those shutdown innings, especially after the offense gets the momentum,” Bednar said.
In total, the bullpen retired 20 of the final 22 hitters it faced. No Blue Jay reached second base after the fourth inning.
The bullpen’s night of redemption
Just days earlier, the Yankees bullpen had been under heavy criticism. They gave up runs in bunches in Games 1 and 2, and their reliability was in question heading into Tuesday. But when the team needed them most, they delivered a flawless performance.
“It was a gutsy effort from all those guys,” Boone said. “They kept us in it, kept it quiet, and gave us a chance to finish the job.”
The performance also marked one of the best bullpen efforts in recent Yankees postseason history. Not since the 2017 ALCS had the team’s relievers combined for nearly seven scoreless innings in an elimination game.
Every arm played a part. Cruz set the tone. Doval and Hill steadied the middle innings. Williams bridged the gap. Bednar finished it off.
The Yankees’ relievers threw 100 pitches combined. Only one ball left the infield after the fifth inning.
Confidence restored in the bullpen
For weeks, fans and analysts had pointed to the bullpen as a weak spot. Injuries, inconsistency, and fatigue had hurt them through September. But Game 3 changed that narrative.
Cruz, a midseason call-up, proved he could handle pressure. Doval, often shaky with command, found precision. Hill rediscovered his rhythm. Williams adapted to a longer role. Bednar established himself as a legitimate closer under postseason pressure.
“That’s how you win playoff games,” Boone said. “You pass the baton, one arm to the next, and trust that each guy will get his outs.”
The Yankees bullpen not only preserved the lead — it rebuilt belief. Their collective performance turned what looked like another October collapse into a season-saving masterpiece.
Judge’s blast may headline the story, but the night belonged to the relievers who refused to let the season end.
On a night filled with emotion, noise, and pressure, the Yankees bullpen stood tall and delivered redemption, pitch by pitch.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
- Categories: Aaron Judge, Camilo Doval, Carlos Rodón, David Bednar, Devin Williams, Jazz Chisholm Jr., News
- Tags: aaron boone, aaron judge, ALDS, Blue Jays, Carlos Rodon, David Bednar, MLB playoffs, Yankee Stadium, yankees
