‘It’s surreal’: Escarra’s heroics help Yankees escape rain and Rockies


Inna Zeyger
More Stories By Inna Zeyger
- Mother’s Day: How Anthony Volpe’s mom molded him into a Yankee phenom
- Was the Yankees’ Chisholm trade bereft of foresight?
- Insider warns Yankees: ‘Stanton can’t play a full year anymore’
- Complexities surrounding death of Brett Gardner’s son Miller add more doubts
- Yankees’ LeMahieu can’t swallow first-career ejection for muted ‘brutal call’ plaint
Table of Contents
When sunshine finally pierced the clouds above Coors Field on Sunday, it symbolized more than just improved weather conditions—it represented a breakthrough moment for a ballplayer whose road to professional baseball was far from illuminated. J.C. Escarra, the 30-year-old backstop who previously earned income as an Uber driver, produced a personal-best three-hit showcase to guide the New York Yankees beyond the Colorado Rockies in a 5-4 triumph that concluded a chaotic afternoon and nerve-wracking series.
The contest featured everything—weather interruptions, closing-inning tension, and October-caliber drama. Yet it also showcased genuine emotion. Escarra’s passion, specifically, remained prominently visible throughout.
From side jobs to spotlight moments
Escarra’s route to Major League Baseball defies typical rookie narratives. Only a few seasons ago, he balanced independent league baseball with additional employment, attempting to preserve his diamond aspirations. Today, he’s contributing decisive hits during crucial contests for baseball’s most storied organization.
“It’s surreal,” Escarra reflected afterward. “Just from what I was doing. Sometimes I sit back and I think about it — where I’m at today, who I’m playing with, the name on my jersey. It’s incredible.”
On Sunday, that emblem—New York Yankees—achieved victory through compelling theater, as Escarra’s eighth-inning RBI base hit provided the cushion they would urgently require to withstand Colorado’s final rally attempt.

A contest demanding determination
The Yankees approached the series conclusion seeking to eliminate memories of an unusual defeat that opened the three-game sequence. Weather conditions proved challenging throughout most of the day—overcast skies, rumbling thunder, electrical activity, and a 1-hour, 46-minute interruption during the fifth frame.
Before atmospheric conditions improved, Aaron Judge doubled home the lead run while Jasson Domínguez contributed a towering sacrifice fly to establish a 4-2 advantage just before the suspension. However, the genuine turning point arrived later, when Escarra entered with two outs in the eighth and plated Domínguez to extend the Yankees’ lead to 5-3.
After a three-hit game, JC Escarra tells @M_Marakovits how he's able to stay locked in at the plate.#YANKSonYES pic.twitter.com/tbVy8kRhOb
— YES Network (@YESNetwork) May 26, 2025
“Today was a dogfight,” Escarra observed. “We came out hot yesterday, but the Rockies gave us some trouble that first game and it’s a team we couldn’t take lightly.”
That additional run proved essential in the ninth when closer Luke Weaver surrendered a leadoff home run and consecutive singles before securing the final outs to record his eighth save.
Escarra’s offensive explosion
Escarra began the day batting merely .195, but by the game’s end, his percentage had climbed to .244. His three-hit display included:
- A second-inning RBI double that brought home Anthony Volpe.
- A fourth-inning base hit.
- The eighth-inning game-changing RBI single.
First 3-hit game for JC Escarra 👏
— YES Network (@YESNetwork) May 25, 2025
Watch and Stream LIVE: https://t.co/sWMqNZ0hci pic.twitter.com/ORXcCxVXOd
The breakthrough effort enhanced an expanding collection of major league highlights for Escarra, who made his debut on March 29. He recorded his initial MLB safety on April 3 against Arizona, his maiden homer on April 27 versus Toronto, and a pinch-hit walk-off sacrifice fly against San Diego on May 7.
Each impressive moment appears to strengthen the next. Sunday’s performance demonstrated more than a simple contribution—he influenced a game where every delivery carried significance.
Boone, Warren commend Escarra’s influence

While his offensive output captured attention, Escarra’s defensive work behind home plate has earned confidence in his reserve capacity to replace first-choice Austin Wells.
“He can really swing the bat,” noted Yankees manager Aaron Boone. “But the real good part about it is what he’s bringing behind the plate on the days he catches. I mean, he’s been excellent.”
Will Warren, Sunday’s starting pitcher, shared similar praise. Warren yielded two runs across four innings before rain ended his appearance, but he lauded Escarra’s leadership and chemistry developed during their minor league tenure.
“I’ve seen the grind he puts in every day,” Warren stated. “So to see him have success is awesome.”
Championship culture built through supporting cast
The Yankees maintain their winning trajectory because of depth contributors like Escarra. He doesn’t start daily. He isn’t generating headlines with mammoth home runs or leading statistical categories. Yet he’s fulfilling winning teams’ requirements—covering weaknesses, elevating performance under pressure, and maximizing opportunities.
Escarra ties it up! #RepBX #Yankees pic.twitter.com/KcLUcQtDtV
— Pinstripes Nation (@pinstripesnat) May 25, 2025
This proves particularly valuable during road trips like the current one, where the Yankees now travel west to battle the Angels and Dodgers before returning home. Having Escarra capable of replacing Wells defensively while maintaining offensive production gives Boone scheduling flexibility with rest periods.
Escarra understands his position. He welcomes it completely.
“In the end, that’s the run that was the difference in the game,” he said regarding his eighth-inning RBI. “The more I get out there, the more comfortable I get, but I know my role.”
Yankees continue dominance
With Sunday’s victory, the Yankees advanced to 32-20, reaching 12 games above .500, and retained their AL East division lead. They’ve captured six consecutive series while displaying reliability despite rotation and health obstacles.
Escarra’s development could represent another component that helps sustain this achievement throughout the summer months.
“There was a time when I didn’t really see any light at the end of the tunnel,” Escarra revealed. “I was ready to give up. But I had that hope in my heart that kept me going.”
That optimism has transformed into reality. For Escarra, it’s finally producing rewards—one at bat at a time.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
- Categories: Aaron Judge, News, Will Warren
- Tags: aaron judge, j.c. escarra, will warren
Related posts:
