ARLINGTON, Texas — The line score does not tell the whole story. It rarely does for a 22-year-old making his major league debut against a team that was fighting to avoid a sweep.
Elmer Rodriguez walked four batters and hit one more in four-plus innings during the Yankees’ 3-0 loss to the Texas Rangers on Wednesday. Only 42 of his 80 pitches were strikes. That is the part everyone saw. That is not the only Yankees story worth telling.
His stuff was genuine. His velocity was live. He retired six batters in a row at one point. He escaped two jams before the fifth inning finally caught up with him. His parents, his brother and a cousin had flown from Puerto Rico to watch him pitch in Yankees pinstripes for the first time. He gave them more than just a rough line.
What the numbers do not show
Rodriguez entered Wednesday having walked just seven batters across 21 and a third innings in his four Triple-A starts this season. That rate was among the best at his level. The Yankees debut was a departure from that norm. Four walks and a hit batter in a single outing is not who Rodriguez has been, and the Yankees know it.
Manager Aaron Boone had watched every inning closely. When reporters gathered after the game, he did not frame the outing as a failure. He identified what went wrong while being clear about what the Yankees organization still believes in Rodriguez.
“I thought his stuff was good,” Boone said. “Obviously strike throwing wasn’t as sharp as it’s going to be with him and typically is. But a lot of good out there. You saw his stuff play. I thought his mix of two-seam and four-seam and spinning it a little bit was good. Just a little better on the strike-throwing part and it’s a different line. But still kept us in the game and gave us a chance.”
That assessment carries weight. Boone is not a Yankees manager who flinches at hard questions about his pitchers. When he says he saw good things, the Yankees are behind that read.
The debut, inning by inning
Rodriguez’s first inning in Yankees pinstripes was instructive. He walked two of the first four batters he faced. But he also got out of the inning without allowing a run. That set the template for what Wednesday would become: command issues creating traffic, but competitiveness keeping the damage contained.
He started the second inning facing a bases-loaded jam and escaped. He then retired the next six batters he faced in succession. For a stretch of 18 consecutive outs across the second, third and fourth innings, Rodriguez looked like the pitcher his Triple-A numbers described.
Then came the fifth. He hit leadoff batter Alejandro Osuna with a 95 mph fastball. He walked Ezequiel Duran on seven pitches. Brandon Nimmo followed with a one-hopper that glanced off first baseman Ben Rice’s glove to load the bases. Josh Jung lined a two-run single through the left side and Rodriguez’s night ended there.
Two runs. Four-plus innings. A debut line that looks worse than the actual game felt.
What worked and why the Yankees are encouraged
Rodriguez’s velocity was not an issue. He sat 93 to 96 mph with his four-seamer and sinker throughout the start. His first career strikeout came on a 97 mph sinker to Jung in the first inning that triggered a strike-’em-out, throw-’em-out double play, a sequence that briefly silenced the crowd.
His curveball showed depth. His changeup gave right-handed hitters a different look. Multiple Rangers hitters were beaten on pitches they could not square up. Weak contact was a recurring theme on balls that did find the field. His average launch angle against on contact was barely above the ground. That is who Rodriguez is built to be in the Yankees rotation, a sinker-heavy pitcher who wins with movement rather than pure power.
The walks were the issue. They will not always be the issue. Boone said as much without saying it directly when he described the Yankees rookie’s control problems as something that will sharpen over time.
Rodriguez addressed his Yankees debut with the composure of a pitcher who understands what a first big-league start can be. He was not defensive. He was not discouraged. He was clear-eyed about what he needs to fix and what gave him confidence going forward.
“It’s a good experience being here,” Rodriguez said. “Obviously it’s my first time around, now I’m just trying to learn from all of the good and the bad and just go forward and continue to work.”
At least one more start coming
Rodriguez will get at least one more Yankees start, possibly two, before Carlos Rodon returns from his rehab assignment. The Yankees are not going to rush a judgment based on 80 pitches in a road afternoon game where Eovaldi was on the other side making everyone look bad.
The comparison is worth making. Cam Schlittler walked one batter in seven innings against this same Rangers lineup two days earlier. Nobody expected Rodriguez to match that. What the Yankees needed was a look at whether his arsenal plays at the big league level. They got that Yankees answer, and it was yes. The command will come. It has come before. Wednesday was one start, not a verdict.
His family flew from Puerto Rico for the occasion. He stood on a Yankees major league mound, fired a 97 mph sinker past a big league hitter and told reporters he was going to learn from it. That is not a bad first day. The box score just did not capture it.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
