NEW YORK — The Yankees left Yankee Stadium on Sunday with a series win, a magic number of one and a question they cannot afford to dismiss. Cam Schlittler had just delivered six scoreless innings against the Mets when a 111.5 mph line drive struck the back of his right hamstring on his final pitch. He walked directly to the clubhouse, turning the final out into the day’s biggest concern.
Aaron Boone did not sound alarmed afterward, but he also did not declare the matter closed. The Yankees manager said the ball caught Schlittler hard in the hamstring area and expressed hope that the 25-year-old would be OK. That cautious tone matters with Schlittler central to the club’s postseason plans.
The Yankees improved to 86-63 by taking two of three from the Mets and moved within one result of clinching their ninth postseason berth in 10 seasons. They remain four games behind Tampa Bay in the AL East. Ben Rice and Austin Wells supplied the offense with solo home runs, while Brent Headrick, Paul Blackburn and David Bednar protected the lead after Schlittler exited.
Schlittler’s outing also moved him into the major league ERA lead at 1.95. He allowed one hit, walked two and struck out eight over 94 pitches. The only hit was Brett Baty’s fifth-inning double. Christian Scott took the loss for the Mets after allowing two runs over six innings, and Bednar recorded his 34th save.
Boone’s caution keeps Yankees from calling scare over
The central update came after the Yankees had finished celebrating the Subway Series win. Schlittler said he expects to make his next start, but the Yankees have not announced that the right-hander is completely clear of the effects of the comebacker. No new diagnosis or imaging result had been announced as of Monday afternoon.
Schlittler gave the most encouraging direct update from the clubhouse.
“Feeling good. Hamstring, hard hit. So it’ll be a fun couple days trying to get that recovered. But I think we’re in a good spot,” the Yankees ace said.
The play itself explained why the Yankees will continue to monitor him. Bo Bichette‘s liner came off the bat at 111.5 mph and hit Schlittler behind the right thigh. The ball ricocheted toward home plate, where Wells recovered it and threw Bichette out at first to end the sixth.
Boone echoed the optimism without calling the matter resolved. He said the ball struck Schlittler hard in the hamstring area and expressed hope that the pitcher was OK, leaving the next several days as the key test.
A short delay could alter Yankees’ most important September turn
The timing makes the next few days more important than a routine bruise normally would be. Schlittler is currently lined up to start Saturday, Sept. 19, against Arizona at Chase Field. CBS Sports lists him as the probable Yankees starter for that game.
If the Yankees keep him on normal rest after Arizona, Schlittler would then line up to pitch again Sept. 24 against Tampa Bay at Yankee Stadium. That could put their best starter on the mound in the series finale against the team they are chasing for the AL East.
That is why even a minor interruption matters. The Yankees want Schlittler healthy for October without disturbing a rotation sequence that could place him in their biggest remaining divisional series. Any skipped bullpen session, extra rest day or pushed-back start could change that alignment.
Schlittler’s value is no longer limited to Cy Young race
Boone’s postgame praise underscored how central Schlittler has become to the Yankees. Asked about the pitcher’s value, Boone widened the conversation beyond the Cy Young Award.
“He might be the MVP, too,” Boone said.
The numbers support the broader point. Schlittler is 14-6 with a 1.95 ERA and 228 strikeouts in 184 2/3 innings. He has allowed one run or fewer in 21 of his 31 starts, a Yankees franchise record. He also has 16 starts of at least six innings with no more than one run allowed, another club record.
His road performance adds another layer to the Arizona concern. Schlittler owns a 1.14 road ERA, the lowest by a qualified major league starter since 1995. The Yankees have leaned on that consistency through repeated rotation injuries.
Mets chants give Schlittler extra fuel before scare
The injury concern came after one of Schlittler’s most emotional starts of the season. The Yankees had been beaten 12-2 on Saturday, when Mets fans made themselves heard throughout Yankee Stadium. The Yankees ace pitcher said that atmosphere stayed with him.
“It’s a little frustrating yesterday, just hearing all the Mets chants. Just kind of wanted to make sure I could come in here today and kind of shut that down. Great series win there. It’s always good to win the Subway Series,” Schlittler said.
He did exactly that. Francisco Lindor struck out twice against him, Juan Soto went hitless, and the Mets managed only Baty’s double before Schlittler left. The Yankees bullpen finished the club’s 14th shutout of the season.
Now the Yankees’ focus shifts from what Schlittler did Sunday to what his right hamstring allows him to do this week. His expectation is that he will take the ball in Arizona. Boone’s more guarded reaction leaves one checkpoint first: how Schlittler responds when he resumes his normal between-start throwing and lower-body work.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
