Boone’s Ben Rice decision could spell trouble for Goldschmidt’s Yankees career.
The New York Yankees lead the American League in offensive production, creating what most teams would consider an enviable challenge for manager Aaron Boone—an abundance of productive hitters competing for limited lineup spots. However, beneath this apparent luxury lies a developing roster tension that may soon force a difficult decision: can Ben Rice maintain his lineup presence without relegating Paul Goldschmidt to a reduced role?
This question grows increasingly relevant following Rice’s latest standout performance. The 26-year-old power hitter, initially viewed as merely a temporary replacement for Giancarlo Stanton, appears to be forcing his way into the Yankees’ long-term offensive strategy, potentially at the expense of a former MVP.
Rice blasts into the spotlight
During Sunday’s 12-2 dismantling of the Oakland Athletics at Sutter Health Park, Rice delivered the knockout blow—a fifth-inning grand slam that transformed a manageable deficit into an insurmountable one for Oakland. This home run continues a pattern of impact performances from the Dartmouth graduate, who currently boasts a .905 OPS, eight home runs, and nine doubles as May unfolds.
For a Yankees squad averaging an MLB-leading 5.72 runs per game, Rice has become an essential contributor. His left-handed swing, quick bat, and all-field power make him difficult to exclude from the lineup, even with Giancarlo Stanton’s anticipated return looming.
Boone recently acknowledged that Rice has earned his spot in the lineup, confirming what observers have recognized for weeks. The manager added that if they reach a point requiring creative solutions, they’ll implement necessary adjustments.
The squeeze at first and DH
The outfield situation offers little flexibility. Aaron Judge remains immovable. Cody Bellinger has rediscovered his form. Jasson Domínguez continues developing. And Trent Grisham provides valuable defensive contributions and speed, as well as being hot on offense.
This reality leaves only the designated hitter position potentially available, but Stanton’s return from elbow issues effectively claims that spot. Currently, Rice occupies this role with consistent production and power, but the Yankees committed $12.5 million to Paul Goldschmidt for specific reasons: his Gold Glove defense and veteran leadership were expected to stabilize first base.
If Rice, who can also handle first base duties, maintains his current offensive trajectory, Boone may need to consider reducing Goldschmidt’s playing time or implementing a platoon system. The message becomes increasingly clear: performance may ultimately supersede reputation.
No-go at third
With DJ LeMahieu approaching activation after missing the season’s first months with a calf injury, speculation emerged about moving Rice to third base to accommodate all productive bats. Given Rice’s positional versatility—drafted as a catcher, capable at first base, and even working behind the plate in Sunday’s victory—third base seemed a logical possibility.
Michael Kay, Yankees broadcaster and insider, has repeatedly pursued this line of questioning.
“I’ve asked Aaron Boone three times now—can Ben Rice play third base?” Kay stated, as reported by Essentially Sports. “He shuts it down every time.”
This resistance has puzzled many across baseball. Hall of Famer Joe Torre—originally a catcher—played third base during his career. Boone himself began as a third baseman. Yet Boone remains unwilling to experiment with Rice at the hot corner, despite the potential roster solution.
When questioned about this possibility, Boone offered minimal encouragement: “When we get to a situation, if we’ve got to get a little creative with things, we’ll do that.” This hardly constitutes enthusiasm, and with Jazz Chisholm Jr. sidelined by an oblique strain, LeMahieu is expected to cover second base rather than third.
Rice’s rise: No fluke
Those familiar with Rice’s development trajectory aren’t surprised by his emergence. Selected in the 12th round from the Ivy League in 2021, he captured the Yankees‘ attention during the pandemic-altered minor league seasons. His journey from Futures League MVP to Yankees regular demonstrates both talent and persistence.
He currently ranks third on the team in both home runs and OPS, trailing only Judge and Stanton. His offensive efficiency, combined with defensive flexibility at catcher and first base, makes it increasingly difficult to justify removing him for roster management purposes.
Yet when Stanton returns and LeMahieu regains health, the Yankees will face a difficult decision: either shift Rice to first base—displacing Goldschmidt—or risk benching a productive hitter or even optioning him to the minors.
Boone’s warning Shot
While no public statements have directly questioned Goldschmidt’s position, Boone’s recent deployment of Rice at first base and reluctance to explore alternative arrangements suggest a potential shift in thinking. Even if Goldschmidt maintains productivity, Boone might implement a more fluid platoon system, where performance, not contract value, determines playing time.
This isn’t about disrespecting an established veteran. It’s about maximizing a hot streak and maintaining one of baseball’s most potent lineups at peak efficiency. He enters Sunday with the second-highest average in MLB.
As Boone navigates this delicate balancing act, one reality becomes increasingly apparent: Ben Rice isn’t quietly accepting a secondary role. And if the manager intends to keep his bat in the order, Paul Goldschmidt may need to recalibrate his expectations or his defensive positioning.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
The biggest mistake the NYY GO will do with Stanton is tidy him back onto the active roster. He needs to play at least a full 2 week, 12 game minor league rehab assignment. He doesn’t like it? Too damn bad! He had no Spring Training. I’m tired of him doing his rehab in the big leagues. Besides, the DJ and 2B guys have done pretty good, do no need to rush him.