Yankees’ Bleacher Creatures ready with ‘plenty of things’ to welcome Juan Soto

Follow Us

Countdown to confrontation: Juan Soto and fans both prepared for the Yankees series in the Bronx

When Juan Soto emerges from the visitors’ dugout Friday evening at Yankee Stadium, he’ll face more than just a formidable pitching arsenal and a potent lineup—he’ll confront the unleashed passion of baseball’s most unforgiving faithful.

The narrative writes itself: the former Yankee phenomenon, now sporting Mets colors after inking a staggering 15-year, $765 million contract, confronts his previous employers for the first time. While Soto might downplay it as “just another series,” the Bronx faithful have other plans. Their response isn’t merely brewing—it’s meticulously orchestrated.

Leading this calculated reception is Bleacher Creatures figurehead Mark Chalpin. From his customary perch in Section 203, Row 7, where he orchestrates the legendary roll call each home stand, Chalpin envisions a particularly chilly greeting for Soto.

“I don’t think we can pull it off, but I would like to see us all turn our backs when Soto comes out in the first inning,” Chalpin told NJ Advance Media.

“It’s not gonna be pleasant for him,’’ Chaplin added. “I’m sure he’ll hear plenty of things. Both in English and Spanish.’’ 

The Bronx’s fallen star

Soto’s single-season tenure with the New York Yankees in 2024 delivered statistical brilliance. Alongside Judge, he formed perhaps the most lethal offensive tandem since the Bronx Bomber glory days. Judge closed with a .322 average, 58 homers, and claimed the AL MVP trophy. Soto wasn’t far behind, posting a .288/.430/.563 line with 41 round-trippers and 101 RBIs, finishing as MVP runner-up.

This offensive juggernaut propelled the Yankees to their first Fall Classic appearance since 2009. Following a five-game defeat to Los Angeles, the front office mission became crystal clear: secure Soto’s services long-term.

Despite extending a mammoth 16-year, $760 million proposal—unprecedented in franchise annals—Hal Steinbrenner’s efforts fell short. Steve Cohen’s Mets countered with marginally superior financial terms, bolstered by perks including enhanced family travel accommodations and a clothing allowance for Soto’s mother.

For many pinstripe loyalists, the issue transcended finances. It centered on allegiance.

‘He’s the enemy now’

Yankees radio personality Keith McPherson expressed the sentiment bluntly on WFAN.

“You went across town thinking that we were going to let you live. Hell, no,” McPherson said. “Now you’re about to actually see the Yankee fan — the Bronx Zoo. They’re going to heckle. They’re going to say everything that they could think of.”

Soto anticipates hostility—”It’s going to be 50,000 against one,” he confided to The Post—yet maintains he harbors no second thoughts.

“It was a tough decision,” Soto said. “(The Yankees) were number one … but we couldn’t get it done. I made a decision, and I’m happy that I made it.”

The fans? Their judgment appears sealed. Many believe he leveraged the Yankees for negotiating advantage without genuine commitment to staying. His post-World Series remark that all thirty franchises remained in contention only intensified the perceived betrayal.

Chalpin and fellow Creatures insist they’ll avoid profanity, but promise creative chants, tactical mockery, and authentic Bronx intensity. Even the section’s venerable cowbell performer returns specifically for this occasion, underscoring Friday’s significance.

No hard feelings in the clubhouse

Within the Yankees’ inner sanctum, respect predominates over resentment.

“He performed, so it’s well deserved,” Yankees starter Carlos Rodon said. “Obviously, we’d love to have had Soto in a Yankees uniform for the rest of his career… but he did what was right for him.”

Judge conveyed similar sentiments, though acknowledging disappointment.

“Did it hurt? It’s tough to say,” Judge said. “I loved hitting behind Soto. I loved learning from him… but he made a decision for his family.”

The volume and duration of fan reaction remain unpredictable, but Rodón, slated for Friday’s start, hopes spectators recall Soto’s contributions.

“Just reflecting on last year with Soto… he was pretty amazing for us,” Rodón said. “I bleed blue pinstripes, but I’m hoping fans take it easy on him.”

Yankees after Soto

Paradoxically, Soto’s departure potentially catalyzed the Yankees’ comprehensive roster reconstruction. Without allocating vast payroll resources to Soto, New York pivoted decisively.

They acquired Max Fried, currently 6-0 with an immaculate 1.11 ERA. Cody Bellinger provides left-handed power and defensive versatility across outfield positions. Paul Goldschmidt, secured at $12.5 million for one season, delivers veteran leadership and clutch hitting.

At 25-18, the New York Yankees lead the division, while the Mets top the NL East at 28-16. Soto’s offensive production has accelerated recently—across his previous 15 contests, he’s batting .268 with .589 slugging and five homers. His season figures include an .845 OPS and 143 OPS+ while batting ahead of slugger Pete Alonso.

Nevertheless, Yankees supporters—renowned for elephantine memories and thunderous vocalization—remain unmoved.

A Bronx welcome to reverberate for ages

If Friday unfolds predictably, it represents merely the opening chapter. Soto will return repeatedly throughout his fifteen-year commitment, potentially establishing this Subway Series as the genesis of an enduring metropolitan drama.

Yankees reliever Mark Leiter Jr. offered perspective.

“Every year is a new team. I think the bigger story is the Yankees are playing good and the Mets are playing good.”

But certain transgressions in the Bronx are eternally remembered.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us