Andrew Benintendi, the New York Yankees’ new player, came across as reserved during his introductory press conference on Thursday afternoon, refusing to give the definitive answer everyone wanted to hear.
He hasn’t been vaccinated yet.
He’s not sure if he’ll get vaccinated.
He didn’t even promise that he would be vaccinated by the time the Yankees visit Toronto from September 26 to 28, even though Canadian law requires proof of vaccination when crossing the border.
When asked directly if he would be available to play in the Blue Jays series if the Canadian government did not change its laws, he dodged the question once again.
The harsh reality is that Benintendi will be vaccinated as long as the Canadian government does not abruptly change its vaccination policies.
While it is true that Benintendi has not directly discussed his vaccination status with Yankees officials, he informed Royals GM Dayton Moore about a week ago that if he were traded to an American League contender, he would get vaccinated, according to two officials with direct knowledge of the trade talks.
Moore, in turn, informed all interested parties that Benintendi intended to get vaccinated.
That’s why, of all the teams, the Blue Jays were heavily involved in the talks regarding the Benintendi trade.
The Yankees may have a 1,112-game lead in the American League East and desperately needed Benintendi to be their everyday left fielder, but there was no way they could negotiate for him if they weren’t aware of his decision to get vaccinated.
Of course, Benintendi could have revealed that same information at his press conference on Thursday, but he wisely declined to do so.
Two weeks ago, he watched as Whit Merrifield, a former Royals teammate, was mocked on social media from coast to coast after being identified as one of the ten unvaccinated Royals who were barred from playing in Toronto.
When he hinted that if he were traded to a contender, he might get vaccinated, the backlash grew significantly. He apologized, but the damage was already done.
Benintendi, who spent five years in Boston, is familiar with the media game. He had no intention of saying anything like that to Whitfield. No way. Never say never. It’s an extremely controversial topic.
If he had announced on Thursday that he was getting vaccinated, he would have been accused of being self-centered for allowing a team’s standings to influence his decision to get vaccinated.
Now he can pretend to be undecided. He still has two months before his decision is made public, and by then, he can simply claim that he has learned more about the benefits of the vaccine.
Oh, and since the Yankees are one of the few teams where everyone is vaccinated, he has the potential to be the ultimate team player.
There are no back-page stories. There’s no national embarrassment. Yankees fans consider him a hero. Perfect.
Yankees manager Aaron Boone said he hasn’t discussed it with Benintendi yet, but if he does, you can bet he won’t be telling everyone about it. Why bother saying anything at this point? The Yankees aren’t scheduled to visit Toronto for another two months.
In fact, Benintendi has already proven to the Yankees’ front office that he is a team player. After the Royals’ afternoon game against the Los Angeles Angels, he was told he would be traded to the Yankees. It wasn’t official yet, but Royals executives let him know and allowed him to make a few phone calls, pack his belongings, and wait as the last player to board the team plane bound for New York.
The agreement was reached during the first inning of the Yankees’ game against the Mets, but it wasn’t made public until after the game. However, when asked on Thursday when he was informed of his trade, he said that manager Mike Matheny told him after they arrived in New York.
Benintendi spent the rest of the night at the Royals’ team hotel making phone calls and playing cards with his now-former teammates. On Thursday, he drove to Yankee Stadium, turned right instead of left down the hallway, entered the Yankees’ clubhouse, and became a member of an iconic franchise with the best record in baseball.
Benintendi was in the starting lineup and playing left field on Thursday, where he will remain for the entire season. This allows the Yankees to use Aaron Judge in right field more often instead of center field. And it pushes Joey Gallo to the bench—if not out of the picture entirely—with Aaron Hicks playing center field and Giancarlo Stanton as the primary designated hitter.
If Benintendi—who helped the Red Sox win the World Series in 2018—can do the same for the Yankees this season, he’ll be fondly remembered in New York.
You know, not based on their vaccination status, but on their actual performance.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.



















