NEW YORK — The pressure was on for Cam Schlittler Monday night. The rookie right-hander may have felt it.
His third audition for a permanent spot in the New York Yankees rotation hit another snag Monday night. The 24-year-old rookie allowed three earned runs on seven hits over 4⅓ innings in a 4-2 loss to the Tampa Bay Rays at Yankee Stadium.
Despite showcasing electric stuff that has made him one of baseball’s most intriguing pitching prospects, Schlittler’s command issues continued to plague his development at the major league level.
The imposing 6-foot-6 right-hander got off to a rocky start, surrendering a two-run homer to Junior Caminero in the first inning after walking Jonathan Aranda on nine pitches. The sequence epitomized Schlittler’s growing pains as he transitions from prospect to rotation piece.
“I actually thought Cam made a lot of good pitches against Aranda,” manager Aaron Boone said. “He kept spoiling, spoiling, spoiling.”
Schlittler’s electric stuff falls to erratic command
Corey Sipkin for the NY POST
Schlittler showed flashes of brilliance with a blazing 98 mph fastball and five strikeouts. The velocity averaged 97.9 mph against Tampa Bay, but the rookie struggled to harness that power effectively. Control problems plagued his outing. He issued four walks and allowed a crucial two-run homer to Junior Caminero in just 4⅓ innings of work.
The Massachusetts native threw 62 fastballs out of 86 total pitches, relying heavily on his best weapon while searching for consistency with his secondary offerings.
“Hitters make quick adjustments. They’re going to make you pay if you’re not in the zone,” Schlittler explained after the loss. “Not being able to execute the fastball allows them to lay off that pitch and focus on some other things. The biggest thing is just trying to work ahead and limiting the walks.”
Those walks proved costly throughout the evening. Schlittler issued four free passes, including three in the opening frame that set up Caminero’s 27th home run of the season.
Boone praised Schlittler’s fastball as “big and real.” But secondary pitches remain a work in progress. Schlittler fell behind in counts repeatedly and couldn’t locate his breaking balls consistently.
“I think the first two [starts] were a lot better than today,” Schlittler admitted. “I’ve got to work on getting [my secondary pitches] in the zone a little bit more, putting them in better spots and better counts.”
Rookie’s rotation spot in debate
The rookie settled down after the disastrous first inning, blanking the Rays from the second through most of the fifth. His night ended when Josh Lowe lined an 0-2 fastball for a go-ahead RBI single in the fifth inning.
“I think the first two [starts] were a lot better than today,” Schlittler admitted. “I scattered seven hits over 4⅓ innings, walking four and striking out five in an 86-pitch effort.”
But the Yankees face tough decisions with their starting rotation. Luis Gil and Ryan Yarbrough are close to returning from injury. Max Fried and Carlos Rodón already anchor the staff.
Schlittler’s grip on a rotation spot has weakened. His ERA sits at 4.91 across 14⅔ major league innings after allowing seven hits Monday night.
The approaching trade deadline adds another layer of complexity. New York needs proven arms, not development projects.
Schlittler possesses the hardest fastball among Yankees starters this season. His slider, curveball, sweeper, and sinker need refinement. Boone called improving the secondary mix “a work in progress” while crediting the rookie’s recent improvements.
The outing wasn’t completely negative. Schlittler made adjustments after the difficult first inning.
From the second through fifth innings, he shut down Tampa Bay. Josh Lowe ended the strong stretch with a 0-2 fastball lined to center for the go-ahead hit.
Mechanical adjustments and veteran guidance
Between innings, Schlittler sought advice from veteran starter Max Fried about his delivery mechanics. The consultation appeared to help as the rookie regained his rhythm temporarily.
“I was talking to Max in between innings, just trying to get some small cues and see what I was feeling out there with the mechanics,” Schlittler said. “I think I was opening up a little bit.”
Cody Bellinger praised the rookie’s composure despite the struggles. The outfielder described Schlittler’s arsenal as “electric” and noted he is “fun to play behind”.
Arsenal development remains key focus
Boone emphasized that refining Schlittler’s secondary pitches represents the next phase of his development. The rookie’s arsenal includes a mid-80s slider, curveball, sweeper and occasional sinker, but none yet match the quality of his fastball.
“I’m confident in the shapes. I think they’re good, plus pitches,” Schlittler said. “I’ve got to work on getting them in the zone a little bit more, putting them in better spots and better counts.”
His sweeper has shown particular promise this season, generating over a foot of horizontal break and producing a 55.6% whiff rate in spring training appearances. The pitch represents the type of weapon that could transform Schlittler from prospect to reliable starter.
The road head for rookie
Rated as MLB Pipeline’s No. 95 overall prospect, Schlittler entered Monday’s start with a 4.91 ERA across 14⅔ innings in his brief big league career.
Schlittler’s struggles come as the Yankees face difficult decisions about their starting rotation. The rookie’s performance Monday highlighted the growing pains that accompany his accelerated development timeline.
While Schlittler has shown the ability to complete five innings in consecutive starts, his command inconsistencies raise questions about his readiness for sustained major league success.
Manager Boone noted that Schlittler threw his fastball 72% of the time against Tampa Bay, suggesting the need for greater confidence in his secondary offerings.
“One of his calling cards is his ability to fill up the strike zone,” Boone said before the game. “The fastball is big and real.”
Offense goes silent again
The Yankees showed early life at the plate. Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Ryan McMahon drew bases-loaded walks in the first inning to tie the game at two runs apiece.
That surge proved short-lived. New York managed just one baserunner from the second through seventh innings. The offensive drought continues a troubling pattern since the All-Star break.
Monday marked the fourth loss in five games for the Yankees. They’ve dropped six of their last 10 contests overall.
Their AL East record stands at a concerning 11-19. Division title hopes continue to fade with each loss to rivals.
“We just weren’t able to mount enough,” Boone said. “And couldn’t hold them down just enough.”
Bellinger Stays Positive, Bullpen Delivers
Yes Network@X
Cody Bellinger remains one of the few Yankees hitting with confidence. He expressed faith in the team’s character despite recent struggles.
“I like showing up every day and going about it with these boys… We’ve just got to keep focusing on what we can control,” Bellinger said.
Cody Bellinger had a productive night at the plate, going 1-for-4 with a run scored, and made a sliding catch. The outfielder reflects on the loss with @M_Marakovits and the rest of the media. #YANKSonYESpic.twitter.com/yZTFpinfr6
The veteran outfielder praised Schlittler’s potential despite Monday’s setbacks. He called the rookie’s stuff “electric” and said he’s “fun to play behind.”
The Yankees bullpen provided a bright spot with 4⅔ innings of one-run relief. Frequent traffic on the bases remained an issue. GM Brian Cashman continues seeking bullpen help before the July 31 deadline.
Schlittler represents both promise and uncertainty for the Yankees. He’s a hard thrower with electric stuff who can dominate hitters. But major league adjustments continue to challenge him.
Whether he develops those skills in the Bronx or elsewhere may be decided by next week’s deadline.
