NEW YORK — The New York Yankees face a familiar problem. Hal Steinbrenner sees it. The coaching staff sees it. The players see it. The question now is whether the organization can correct what went wrong during the 2025 season.
Speaking with reporters on Monday, the Yankees owner pointed to one core issue that pushed the team off track. It was not a shortage of talent. It was not a lack of pitching depth. It came down to simple execution.
Steinbrenner said the team struggled with mental mistakes that hurt them from spring through October.
“Mental mistakes, baserunning for sure, which is why we made a coaching change,” Steinbrenner said, according to MLB.com’s Bryan Hoch. “That has been a thorn in our side most of the season this year.”
Coaching heads already rolled
The Yankees did not wait long to make changes when the postseason run ended. First base coach Travis Chapman and bullpen coach Mike Harkey were dismissed in October after the team fell to the Toronto Blue Jays in the American League Division Series. Chapman had worked as first base and infield coach since 2022. Harkey had spent 16 years in the organization across multiple stints.
Steinbrenner’s remarks confirmed that baserunning failures were a major part of the decision. The Yankees spent much of the summer dealing with avoidable mistakes. A road trip in Miami after the trade deadline stood out. Steinbrenner pointed to that series as a time “where we were making mistakes, not playing good baseball, not hitting. That can’t happen.”
Those lapses cost the Yankees control of the AL East. The team entered July at the top of the division, then watched Toronto surge past them and stay there through the finish.
Players shoulder the blame for October
Some fans questioned Aaron Boone’s role in the late season slide. Steinbrenner dismissed that idea.
“He makes overall good decisions on the field,” he said. “You can’t pin this on Aaron Boone, that’s for sure. This Toronto series was on the players’ shoulders, period.”
Toronto controlled the season matchup. The Blue Jays won eight of 13 regular season games. They then took down the Yankees in four games in the ALDS. Steinbrenner said the Yankees did not “play up to their potential” in October. Toronto delivered cleaner and sharper baseball.
The Yankees ended the season with 94 wins. They beat the Red Sox in the Wild Card Series but fell short again. The franchise has not won a championship since 2009. The drought is now 16 years.
The boom or bust Yankees offense
Steinbrenner also pointed to an issue that has frustrated Yankees fans for a long time. The offense leans too heavily on home runs. When balls stop leaving the park, the run production dips. Sloppy baserunning makes it worse. Missed chances add up.
The 2025 team swung between high scoring nights and long scoring droughts. That inconsistency proved damaging during the stretch when they lost control of the division.
After the ALDS, Blue Jays bench coach Don Mattingly, a former Yankees captain, noted that Toronto stuck to a daily mindset of intensity and accountability. “It’s the little things I saw, like winning the first two games of a three-game series without anyone ever telling himself, ‘We can afford to lose this one today,'” Mattingly said.
Toronto played with that focus all year. Whether the Yankees can adopt that approach is a challenge the team must confront.
Boone stays while staff changes
Boone will return for a ninth season as manager. His contract runs through 2027. His staff, however, will look different. Along with Chapman and Harkey leaving, hitting coach James Rowson received permission to interview for the Minnesota Twins’ managerial opening. If he departs, the Yankees will need a new voice for a lineup that ranked among baseball’s strongest.
Third base coach Luis Rojas has also explored roles outside the organization. The moves mark the biggest staff changes since Boone took the job in 2018.
Boone’s critics remain vocal. They point to lineup decisions, bullpen usage and his support of shortstop Anthony Volpe. Volpe committed 17 errors this season. Steinbrenner has not reached the point of moving on from Boone.
What comes next in the Bronx
The Yankees enter the offseason with several roster questions.
“We’re looking at every area of need, and we will determine which needs are most significant and which aren’t,” Steinbrenner said. “We still need another outfielder; we have options. We need to improve the bullpen, for sure. I really love our starting rotation next year.”
The Yankees have been mentioned as a possible landing spot for Cody Bellinger. They have also been linked to free agent Kyle Tucker. Outfielder Trent Grisham accepted a qualifying offer worth 22.025 million dollars. Steinbrenner said the 2025 payroll reached 319 million dollars. He prefers lowering that figure but said the team may need to keep spending.
“Would it be ideal if it went down? Of course,” he said. “But does that mean that’s going to happen? Of course not. We want to field a team we know can win a championship, or we believe could win a championship.”
The starting rotation should be a strength if Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodon stay healthy. Both missed long stretches of the season. For the Yankees, the problem has not been talent. The problem has been execution. The problem has been mental mistakes. The problem has been accountability.
Steinbrenner says the Yankees understand that. How they respond in 2026 will decide whether this era changes or the drought continues.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
