Yankees Nation demolishes insider for utterly ‘useless’ Gerrit Cole update


Esteban Quiñones
More Stories By Esteban Quiñones
- Mother’s Day: How Anthony Volpe’s mom molded him into a Yankee phenom
- Pirates’ recent moves open door for Yankees pursuit of Paul Skenes
- Is President Trump behind MLB decision to reinstate Pete Rose?
- Yankees add another aging veteran arm disregarding warning signs
- Max Fried claims Yankees 88-year-old record despite losing perfect start
Table of Contents
The realm of sports reporting thrives on timely, relevant updates, but when such information seems trivial or redundant, the reaction can be unforgiving. This was the case when NJ.com beat writer Randy Miller offered what he likely perceived as a harmless, quick update on New York Yankees star pitcher Gerrit Cole. However, the Yankees faithful deemed it not only insufficient but provocatively unnecessary amid growing concerns over Cole’s elbow health.
Unrelenting fan backlash on ‘useless’ Gerrit Cole update
Miller’s innocuous tweet detailing a brief encounter with Gerrit Cole was met with a storm of derision from Yankees supporters, who lambasted the journalist for what they saw as a non-update during a critical moment. Fans didn’t hold back, unleashing comments like “This might be rock bottom of sports reporting” and “I’d also walk as fast as I could away from Randy Miller.” Others suggested Miller should “deactivate your account,” emphasizing the depth of their displeasure.
I was just walking to the Yankees clubhouse and Gerrit Cole popped out of a back door right in front of me. I said, ‘Hey Gerrit, how are you feeling.” Walking fast away from me, he answered, Good, thanks for asking.” No word yet on results from Monday’s MRI on his elbow.
— Randy Miller (@RandyJMiller) March 12, 2024
Such sharp reactions reflect more than just dissatisfaction with one reporter’s tweet; they reveal the heightened tensions within the Yankees community, particularly given the ambiguity surrounding Cole’s condition. After Manager Aaron Boone announced Gerrit Cole’s MRI due to elbow issues, fans were understandably anxious, parsing every piece of information for clarity on their ace’s prognosis. When Miller’s update failed to provide substantive news, it was seen as not just irrelevant but insensitive to the fans’ palpable anxiety.
Great tweet. This is some sportscenter level reporting right here. Do you think I can get a clubhouse pass, since they are just handing them out to anyone?
— Brian Trashman (@NYYTrash) March 12, 2024
Wow! Absolutely riveting! You left us in suspense about what he was wearing! Such a cliffhanger.
— Jeet3465 (@PCatuogno) March 12, 2024
This might be rock bottom of sports reporting.
— STANNIS (@Fern_DR) March 12, 2024
Update: Gerrit Cole’s health and Dylan Cease trade rumors
Amidst the ongoing worry over Cole’s health, the Yankees’ actions have only amplified speculation and concern. The club’s pursuit of Chicago White Sox pitcher Dylan Cease, as reported by Bob Nightengale of USA Today, suggests New York is bracing for the possibility of a significant void in their rotation. The team’s reported offer, notably excluding outfield prospect Spencer Jones, indicates a cautious but intentional approach to bolstering their pitching staff in light of uncertainty.

Cease, who has shown resilience and skill on the mound despite a challenging season with the White Sox, represents a potentially crucial acquisition for the Yankees. With a rotation already riddled with questions beyond Cole, including the consistency of newcomers and the recovery of struggling stars, the need for a reliable arm is paramount. As Opening Day looms, the team’s management and fans alike are acutely aware that the success of the 2024 season could hinge significantly on how they navigate this period of doubt and decision-making.
The Yankees, while awaiting news on Gerrit Cole, have re-engaged with the Chicago White Sox and made a new proposal for ace Dylan Cease, but the new offer once again did not include prized outfield prospect Spencer Jones.
— Bob Nightengale (@BNightengale) March 12, 2024
In conclusion, while fans’ scathing response to Miller’s update might seem harsh, it underscores the intense passion and high expectations within the Yankees community. As the team looks ahead, the focus will undoubtedly remain on securing a healthy and competitive rotation, hopefully with or horribly without Cole at the forefront. What do you think? Leave your comment below!
- Categories: Fan Reactions, Gerrit Cole, News
- Tags: gerrit cole, New York Yankees, spring training 2024

Yankees already have Cole’s “rellacement” on the team. Open your eyes, Bomber loyalists, for there is more than ine quality player on our 40-man+ roster!