New York — Hal Steinbrenner has spent weeks complaining about payroll. He told reporters he would prefer to see the Yankees’ spending go down. He pleaded poverty despite running one of the most valuable franchises in sports.
Five of his players just got raises anyway.
MLB announced the distribution of its Pre-Arbitration Performance Bonus Pool this week. The Yankees saw five players cash in for a combined total of roughly $1.5 million. The timing could not have been more ironic.
Austin Wells leads the pack
The primary catcher took home the largest bonus among Yankees players. Austin Wells received $392,768 from the pool.
The payout reflected his progress behind the plate. MLB’s bonus model incorporates advanced catching metrics like framing runs, blocking value and throwing efficiency. Wells showed improvement in all three areas during his second full big league season.
His offensive production helped as well. Wells provided steady on-base skills throughout 2025 while continuing to develop as a hitter. The combination pushed him comfortably into the bonus tier.
The 25-year-old figures to enter 2026 as the undisputed starter at catcher. This bonus serves as early validation of his emergence.
Ben Rice cashes in on breakout campaign
The first baseman earned $375,943 for a season that exceeded all expectations.
Ben Rice entered 2025 as a platoon option behind Paul Goldschmidt. He left it as a middle-of-the-order bat the Yankees plan to build around.
The lefty slugger added over ten pounds of muscle during the offseason. That translated to a two mph increase in bat speed and three mph jump in average exit velocity. He crushed 26 home runs and posted a 133 wRC+ while playing first base, catcher and designated hitter.
Rice ranked among the game’s elite in quality of contact. He finished in the 92nd percentile or better in exit velocity, hard-hit rate, barrel rate and expected wOBA. The pre-arb formula rewards exactly that kind of production.
His plate discipline and left-handed power graded favorably among rookie first basemen. The bonus pool recognized what Yankees fans already knew: Rice is the real deal.
Trade deadline steal gets his share
Jose Caballero arrived in perhaps the most dramatic fashion imaginable. The Yankees acquired him from the Tampa Bay Rays on deadline day while the two teams were playing each other. He hugged his former teammates goodbye and walked across the field to join his new club.
He made the most of his opportunity. Caballero led MLB in stolen bases with 49 on the season. His speed and defensive versatility made him exactly the type of under-the-radar contributor the bonus pool was designed to reward.
The 29-year-old collected $269,841 from the pool. He played second base, third base, shortstop and all three outfield positions. His above-average defensive metrics at multiple spots and efficient base-stealing allowed him to accumulate value that translated directly into bonus money.
In 34 games for the Yankees, Caballero slashed .258/.351/.470 with three home runs and 14 stolen bases. The Rays have already moved on from the player they sent the other direction.
Two young arms round out the list
Will Warren received $223,911 for eating innings when the Yankees needed them most.
The pre-arb formula places real weight on workload. Warren delivered stable rotation innings while Gerrit Cole recovered from Tommy John surgery. He led all qualified rookie pitchers in starts with 33, innings pitched with 162.1 and strikeouts with 171. His strikeout-to-walk profile held up and his run prevention metrics sat around league average for a young starter.
The reliability alone vaulted him high enough to secure bonus money.
Cam Schlittler earned $223,864 for a meteoric rise that captivated the fanbase.
The 24-year-old began the season at Double-A Somerset. He ended it making a postseason start with the season on the line. His eight scoreless innings against the Red Sox in the Wild Card Series featured 12 strikeouts and no walks. No pitcher in postseason history had posted that exact stat line before.
Schlittler compiled a 2.96 ERA across 73 regular season innings. His three fastballs regularly sat at 98 mph. Pitchers earn bonus pool money through performance in high-pressure situations and strikeout rates. Schlittler checked every box.
How the bonus pool works
MLB introduced the Pre-Arbitration Performance Bonus Pool in the 2022 collective bargaining agreement. The goal was simple: get young players paid closer to their actual value.
Before this system, players generated enormous value while earning close to the league minimum. Full salary arbitration does not begin until a player accrues three years of service time. The bonus pool addresses that gap.
Every team contributes roughly $1.67 million to a $50 million total pot. That money gets distributed to players with less than three service years who perform at a high level.
Awards voting determines some payouts. Winning MVP or Cy Young nets $2.5 million. The remaining money gets allocated through a WAR formula that factors in playing time and advanced metrics.
Pirates ace Paul Skenes topped this year’s pool with a record $3.4 million. A total of 101 players received payments.
The $1.5 million going to these five Yankees will not change the team’s offseason spending plans. The amounts are modest in relative terms. But coming against Steinbrenner’s complaints about money, the timing feels fitting.
The young core is getting paid. The owner can figure out the rest.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
