Yankees fans in disarray as Aaron Judge’s injury sparks fury, disbelief

Matthew Maybloom
More Stories By Matthew Maybloom
- Mother’s Day: How Anthony Volpe’s mom molded him into a Yankee phenom
- Yankees’ Cody Bellinger chase takes ugly turn after fruitless meetings
- Yankees bid for Corey Seager trade, but what they have to give up
- Yankees cause a stir with rare Rule 5 choice that bucks the trend
- Tatsuya Imai goes ballistic on Dodgers, but Yankees news brings no relief
Table of Contents
Tuesday proved to be a challenging day for devoted supporters of the New York Yankees, as adversity struck from multiple angles. Firstly, the team suffered a defeat at the hands of the formidable Chicago White Sox during the opening game of the series. Adding to their woes, the Yankees’ star player, Aaron Judge, found himself sidelined due to an unfortunate injury.
Following Tuesday’s game, Yankees manager Aaron Boone addressed the media, revealing that the slugger would be placed on the 10-day injured list. This decision was made due to a bruise and sprain in a ligament of Aaron Judge’s prominent right toe. Reports indicate that Aaron Judge underwent a platelet-rich plasma injection to aid his recovery, fortunately avoiding a fracture.
This marks Judge’s second stint on the injured list this season, having missed ten games in late April and early May due to a hip injury. Regrettably, during that period, the Yankees suffered six losses out of ten games.
Manager Aaron Boone clarified that no fracture was found, but Judge’s diagnosis included a contusion and a sprained ligament, without a specified timeline for his return to the team’s lineup.
The toe injury occurred on Saturday when Judge executed a spectacular catch against the Los Angeles Dodgers. In his efforts to prevent J.D. Martinez from gaining extra bases in a 6-3 victory, Judge collided with the Dodger Stadium bullpen gate, propelled by the sheer force of his 282-pound frame.
Concerns surrounding Judge’s health persisted since that incident, with Boone informing reporters earlier on Tuesday that the player would be examined by a team doctor. Boone expressed optimism that Judge’s time on the injured list would be brief, as the primary issue at present is the swelling in his toe.
This unfortunate setback interrupts what has been yet another remarkable season for Judge. Leading Major League Baseball in home runs with 19, he currently maintains a batting average of .291/.404/.674, boasting a league-leading 1.078 OPS. These statistics closely rival his exceptional performance in 2022, which garnered him the AL MVP award and the American League home run record.
Judge underwent platelet-rich plasma (PRP) injections as part of his treatment for the injuries.
“Can’t replace that guy, from a leadership standpoint, from a playing standpoint,” Josh Donaldson told about Aaron Judge. “We’re just going to really have to come together as a team. Play good defense, pitch, throw the ball well, and hopefully keep winning games until he gets back.”
The Yankees were already grappling with injuries to other outfielders, with Harrison Bader sidelined due to a hamstring strain. Giancarlo Stanton, who recently returned from a hamstring strain of his own, is currently limited to the designated hitter role to avoid further setbacks. The team exercises caution in rushing Stanton back to the outfield to prevent additional injuries.
At present, no definite timeline exists for Judge’s return, leaving the Yankees anxiously awaiting further evaluation results. The team must adapt their lineup and hope that other players can step up to fill the void created by Judge’s absence.
Fans wary of Yankees’ fate without Aaron Judge
Important to note about right big toe injuries re: Aaron Judge. DJ LeMahieu tried to play through last year and he couldn't generate any power in his swing. While we don't know diagnosis, speaks to the importance of being able to plant and turn on that back foot. #Yankees
— Brendan Kuty 🧟♂️ (@BrendanKutyNJ) June 6, 2023
You can’t call Aaron Judge the “most valuable” Yankee when he misses half a season with minor injuries. He stubs his toe in LA and he’ll be out for what? Two months? Mickey Mantle had many worse injuries than Judge and he used to play through a lot of them.
— Charles Samuel Dworak (@charlesdworak) June 7, 2023
Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton and Harrison Bader have not started one game together this season. pic.twitter.com/CePEe4iCdA
— Mike Daddino (@mike_daddino) June 7, 2023
For fucks sake! This is the most injured team I’ve ever seen. I know Judge’s was just bad luck but the arm injuries year after year are just incredible. Here’s to treading water 🍻
— Eric Stross (@Swampystheman) June 7, 2023
Judge is very fragile, no Ironman like Lou Gehrig, always something to injure himself. Right now, it's not a good time to be Judge less.
— Severin Lourenco (@SeverinLouren10) June 7, 2023
Dear @TheJudge44,
— JP_YankeesGirl (@90syankskid) June 6, 2023
Please don’t leave us for the IL. Our hearts can’t take it. 😭🙏🏻🫶🏻#repbx #allrise #aaronjudge #Yankees #yankeestwitter #MLB pic.twitter.com/VEGViaBobr
I feel at this point us Yankee fans know what’s going to be the outcome- both will be on the IL and Judge may be out longer than we would like
— Trachiel Tallchief (@Trachiel_24) June 6, 2023
Why do the Yankees have to jerk the fans around like this? Surely there has to be a better way to answer these questions than Boone does here.
— John Deam (@JohnDeam8) June 6, 2023
The IL revolving door, training/medical staff, and gaslighting with the Yankees the last several years is maddening
— Ryan Hutzel (@ryhutzel) June 6, 2023
Baseball fans everywhere lining up to donate their toe to Aaron Judge #YankeesTwitter #RepBX #Sad pic.twitter.com/pxmtHsftNL
— Captain's Corner (@Captain2Corner) June 6, 2023
Yankees put up such a smoke screen regarding Aaron Judge's toe that it's engulfed the East Coast.
— Brendan Kuty 🧟♂️ (@BrendanKutyNJ) June 6, 2023
Yankees being no hit
— Ty (@TyTroll) June 7, 2023
Aaron Judge broke his toe
Season is over pic.twitter.com/T3TulPs36N
Aaron Judge must Is 1of The Best players in the league you also is a liability always getting hurt and that hurts the yankees now he's hurt again two times this year already
— Tony Garcia (@TonyGar34922575) June 7, 2023
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
- Categories: Aaron Judge, News, Reactions
- Tags: aaron judge, Yankees fans
Follow Us







