Yankees’ Cabrera set for ankle surgery on May 15, reminds Jeter’s 2012 ordeal

Follow Us

Oswaldo Cabrera is to undergo ankle surgery on May 15, as his injury reminds the Yankees of Derek Jeter’s 2012 setback.

What began as a routine sacrifice fly ended in devastating fashion for Oswaldo Cabrera and the New York Yankees this week. The emerging infielder is now scheduled for ankle surgery on Thursday, May 15, following a wrenching injury sustained while scoring against the Seattle Mariners. As uncertainty clouds his return timeline, the incident has stirred unsettling parallels to Derek Jeter‘s catastrophic ankle fracture during the 2012 ALCS — a moment that altered both a playoff run and a legendary career.

Injury sends Cabrera to the OT

The fateful play unfolded during Monday night’s ninth inning at T-Mobile Park. Cabrera tagged from third on an Aaron Judge sacrifice fly, and as he maneuvered around catcher Cal Raleigh to reach home plate, his left ankle collapsed beneath him. Though he successfully scored, Cabrera immediately crumpled in excruciating pain.

Medical staff rushed to attend to the fallen infielder. Following an extended delay that silenced the Seattle crowd, Cabrera departed via ambulance with his leg immobilized in an air cast, leaving teammates visibly shaken.

“He was just starting to come into his own,” DJ LeMahieu remarked solemnly. “Super unfortunate. Great guy. Great player.”

Surgery set for May 15, severity to be determined

After initial evaluation at Harborview Medical Center in Seattle, Cabrera returned to New York aboard Hal Steinbrenner’s private aircraft for a comprehensive assessment. Dr. Justin Greisberg, a respected orthopedic foot and ankle specialist, will oversee his care.

Manager Aaron Boone confirmed the surgical plan while acknowledging remaining uncertainties.

“We’ll get a plan of action with Dr. Greisberg,” Boone stated Tuesday. “Surgery is in play potentially on Thursday, but we’ll know more in the next 24 to 48 hours.”

When questioned about Cabrera’s prospects for returning this season, Boone offered candid uncertainty.

“I have no idea,” he conceded. “If they go in there, they’ll get a better idea of what’s needed. Then we’ll see.”

Parallels to Derek Jeter’s 2012 ankle fracture

For the Yankees community, Cabrera’s agonizing collapse evoked immediate flashbacks to Derek Jeter’s left ankle fracture during the 2012 ALCS Game 1. The iconic shortstop went downfielding a routine grounder in extra innings, abruptly ending his postseason. Despite surgical intervention, complications limited Jeter to just 17 appearances the following year.

While Cabrera, at 25, faces his setback at a significantly earlier career stage than Jeter did, the emotional resonance has struck a profound chord throughout the organization — another promising season interrupted by a gruesome ankle injury on the basepaths.

Breakout campaign derailed

Before the injury, Cabrera had cemented himself as an invaluable piece amid early roster turbulence, including LeMahieu’s absence. He had started 30 of New York’s first 41 contests, posting a .243 batting average with 11 RBIs and a .631 OPS, while providing defensive versatility across the infield, predominantly at third base.

Beyond statistics, Cabrera’s infectious enthusiasm and adaptability had transformed him into a clubhouse cornerstone.

“He brings energy every day,” Boone observed earlier this month. “He’s become a heartbeat guy for us.”

Now the Yankees must fill the void created by his absence, both tangibly on the field and intangibly in team morale.

A history of Yankees’ ankle misfortunes

Cabrera joins an unfortunate lineage of Yankees sidelined by ankle injuries:

• Greg Bird (2017): A bone bruise necessitated ankle surgery, effectively eliminating his entire season.
• Andy Pettitte (2012): A line drive fractured his fibula just above the ankle, sidelining him for over two months.
• Joba Chamberlain (2012): A recreational trampoline accident resulted in a compound ankle fracture that threatened his season.

Each case followed a unique trajectory, but most led to prolonged absences. The complex nature of ankle injuries — involving intricate combinations of bone, ligament, and weight-bearing considerations — makes recovery particularly unpredictable.

Depth options and a test of resilience

LeMahieu’s return provides timely reinforcement, but the Yankees will likely require additional adjustments. Oswald Peraza and Jorbit Vivas figure to assume expanded roles, while Triple-A alternatives could soon enter consideration.

The psychological impact extends beyond the lineup card. Cabrera had evolved from utility player to unifying presence.

“He was at breakfast with us the next morning,” revealed a team staff member. Smiling, joking, not sulking. That’s Oswaldo.”

Get well soon, Cabrera!

Thursday’s surgical findings will largely determine Cabrera’s rehabilitation timeline. A straightforward break might permit rehab within a matter of months, but ligament complications or joint involvement could jeopardize his entire 2025 campaign.

The Yankees, positioned near the top of the American League East entering mid-May, must push forward despite the significant loss.

“The baseball gods have a cruel way of timing things,” noted one former team trainer. “You just hope it’s not the kind that steals a year from a promising career.”

As Cabrera undergoes surgery on May 15, the organization and fanbase await news with collective anxiety. The run he scored before collapsing momentarily extended a rally, but the aftermath created a void that transcends statistical measurement.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us