Why breaking Hank Aaron’s record means little to Aaron Judge right now

Follow Us

CINCINNATI — Aaron Judge reached another career milestone Monday night, but the New York Yankees captain showed no signs of celebration. His towering 343rd home run moved him past Hank Aaron for most homers through a player’s first decade in the majors.

The blast elevated Judge to seventh place in baseball history for that span, according to Stats Centre. Alex Rodriguez sits next at 345 home runs, a mark the Yankees captain could reach within days.

Yet there were no smiles or acknowledgment of the achievement. The Yankees’ current struggles have dampened any individual joy. With the 5-4 loss in Cincinnati marks the Yankees are now 1-6 in extras this season.

Historic achievement amid team turmoil

Judge now chases baseball immortality alongside legends like Eddie Mathews (370), Ralph Kiner (369), Adam Dunn (354), Ken Griffey Jr. (350), and Albert Pujols (408). His 2025 season ranks among the finest of his career, making those targets increasingly attainable.

He’s posting remarkable numbers: .367/.468/.734 with 28 home runs and a 1.202 OPS. Judge leads the majors in batting average, slugging percentage, and OPS. Even prime Alex Rodriguez never achieved these statistics in pinstripes.

The Yankees captain remains focused elsewhere. Personal records matter little when team success continues slipping away.

Yankees’ June collapse perturbs Judge

New York’s comfortable AL East advantage has shrunk to one game. They’ve dropped nine of 12 games and compiled a disappointing 10-12 June record. A six-game losing streak highlighted their recent struggles, including three consecutive shutouts—the first time in over a century of Yankees history.

Tuesday’s 5-4 extra-inning loss to Cincinnati perfectly captured their current state. Close games turn into defeats. Talent fails to translate into victories. Opportunities become missed chances.

Judge feels the weight of these failures more than anyone.

“We got to play better. That’s it,” he said in the quiet clubhouse afterward. “We’re not playing that great, but we got to learn from it. We got to move on.”

Leadership reigns over legacy

Judge pursues championships rather than individual accolades. His muted reaction to passing Aaron reflects this priority. Wins matter more than records.

“No, we got a lot of winners in this clubhouse,” he added. “You guys know to move on from tough stretches. And you know, we’ve done that before.”

The captain’s words carried determination rather than hollow optimism. He refuses to let this slide define their season. But Judge acknowledges the responsibility belongs to the players.

“It’s on us. We got to figure it out.”

Remarkable efficiency in power production

Judge’s climb through the all-time rankings becomes more impressive considering his injury history. Rodriguez played 1,275 games across his first 10 seasons. Judge missed significant time between 2018 and 2020, accumulating far fewer games. His power production remains elite despite reduced opportunities.

Health permitting, Judge could reach Griffey Jr. (350) and Dunn (354) before the season’s end. The 400-home run mark no longer seems impossible.

Individual excellence can only accomplish so much when surrounded by struggling teammates.

Yankees offensive struggles nullify Judge’s power surge

The Yankees’ offense has stagnated beyond Judge’s contributions. They’re batting .167 with runners in scoring position over 12 games. Paul Goldschmidt and Trent Grisham provide some support, but key players like Anthony Volpe, DJ LeMahieu, and Austin Wells have gone silent.

Manager Aaron Boone has attempted lineup changes, motivational speeches, and private meetings. Nothing has sparked the necessary turnaround. Judge’s heroics feel like footnotes rather than game-changers.

Baseball doesn’t reward individual brilliance alone. Judge would be leading another MVP race in different circumstances. But this concerns the Yankees‘ championship aspirations, not personal achievements.

A season that began with World Series expectations now faces mediocrity. The standings reflect harsh reality. Division rivals continue gaining ground. The AL East no longer feels like New York’s division to lose—it’s become theirs to reclaim.

Judge understands the stakes perfectly.

His home runs make history. His statistics inspire awe. But for Aaron Judge, only one scoreboard matters—the one tracking Yankees’ wins and losses. Lately, it offers no reason to smile.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us