Is this Toronto star reason behind Yankees’ Arenado snub?

Follow Us

Interest in Toronto’s rising infield star may explain the Yankees’ reluctance to pursue Cardinals’ star Nolan Arenado.

The Yankees continue their search for stability on the infield’s left side, with an unexpected candidate now entering the conversation. Industry sources suggest New York has expressed interest in Toronto Blue Jays shortstop Bo Bichette, potentially viewing him as a solution at third base rather than his natural position.

This development follows recent reporting from MLB insider Jon Heyman, who indicated Bichette appears “likely to leave” Toronto following the 2025 season and seems “destined for free agency.” With extension talks apparently stalled and Toronto showing reluctance toward a long-term commitment, Bichette’s availability has caught the attention of several large-market franchises, with the Yankees positioned prominently among them.

Adding credibility to these whispers, The Athletic’s Jim Bowden forecasted in March that Bichette could land a “five-year, $147 million deal” with New York—not to replace Anthony Volpe at shortstop, but instead to reinvent himself at third base, a position entirely new to his major league résumé.

“Bo Bichette signs a five-year, $147 million deal to play third base for the Yankees,” Bowden stated in his 2025 market predictions.

Bichette’s down year opens door to positional flexibility

After a stellar 2023 campaign where he received MVP consideration and produced a .306/.339/.475 slash line, Bichette’s 2024 season represented a significant regression. Limited to just 81 games because of injuries, the shortstop hit a career-worst .225 with a subpar 72 OPS+, marking his first season performing below league-average standards offensively.

Despite this temporary decline, the 26-year-old remains among baseball’s most gifted shortstops at the plate, boasting a lifetime .296 batting average with over 100 doubles and 80 home runs since breaking into the majors in 2019. A resurgent 2025 campaign—particularly in his contract year—could position Bichette as one of the market’s premier talents.

Should Toronto fail to secure an extension, clubs like the Yankees might capitalize, especially if they envision him as the answer to their persistent third base dilemma.

Yankees’ third base conundrum continues

Since Alex Rodriguez‘s departure, the Yankees have struggled to establish consistency at third base. DJ LeMahieu currently remains sidelined with a calf injury, Oswaldo Cabrera has performed capably in a utility role, and Oswald Peraza has shown potential, yet none have cemented themselves as the definitive long-term solution.

Earlier trade speculation connected New York to Nolan Arenado, but those discussions diminished amid concerns regarding his contract magnitude, advancing age, and declining production in 2024. Now, Bichette—younger, potentially more cost-effective, and offensively dynamic—presents an intriguing alternative.

While transitioning from shortstop to third base represents a significant adjustment, the Yankees have precedent for such moves. Alex Bregman, Manny Machado, and Rodriguez himself successfully navigated similar positional shifts. Bichette’s athleticism and arm strength could translate effectively to the hot corner, particularly if New York remains committed to Anthony Volpe as their shortstop of the future.

Is Bo Bichette blocking Arenado?

The Yankees’ apparent interest in Bichette might explain their hesitation to aggressively pursue Arenado, whose defensive excellence and offensive track record once made him an ideal target. However, with $35 million annually owed through 2027 and coming off a disappointing season, Arenado’s fit in New York seems less compelling than previously thought.

If the Yankees believe they can acquire Bichette via free agency—possibly at a reduced price following his 2024 struggles—it would make strategic sense to avoid committing to Arenado and instead target a younger, more adaptable option.

Could Bichette and Volpe coexist?

Though Bichette has exclusively played shortstop throughout his major league career (594 games), the Yankees likely view him as a third baseman by necessity. With Volpe fresh off a Gold Glove season and positioned as a cornerstone of the franchise’s infield future, Bichette would need to change positions to fit into New York’s long-term plans.

Moreover, Bichette’s offensive profile would translate well to third base, especially considering Yankee Stadium’s short right-field dimensions that could amplify his opposite-field power.

What’s next?

Bichette’s contractual situation makes him both a potential midseason trade candidate if Toronto falls from contention or a high-profile free agent target for teams like the Yankees should he reach the open market.

The Blue Jays extending Vladimir Guerrero Jr. with a mega deal, Bichette may become the casualty in Toronto’s financial planning.

For the Yankees, this represents a strategic opportunity. Whether through a midseason trade or winter free agency pursuit, the possibility of Bichette in pinstripes gains credibility—and his acquisition could finally stabilize one of New York’s most problematic positions.

The Yankees’ success has historically been built on bold, calculated acquisitions, and adding Bichette could provide both immediate impact and sustainable value. If he rebounds in 2025 and demonstrates durability throughout a complete season, Bo Bichette might emerge not merely as a contingency plan, but as the centerpiece of New York’s next championship pursuit.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us