LAS VEGAS — The New York Yankees have spent another October watching a different club celebrate. Their latest postseason exit has left a 17-season championship drought, even as owner Hal Steinbrenner continues to field one of baseball’s costliest rosters.
Aaron Boone will manage again in 2027. Brian Cashman remains in charge of constructing the roster. Those decisions preserve the two most visible leaders of a team that has not won the World Series since 2009.
The Yankees now must repair a bullpen with several free agents, sort out their infield and find an offense that can survive without relying on Aaron Judge to carry it.
Into that familiar setting stepped Scott Boras, the influential agent for Gerrit Cole and Cody Bellinger. At the general managers meetings Wednesday, Nov. 11, he questioned whether New York’s resources and leadership were producing the results the franchise expects.
Scott Boras challenges Yankees ownership
Boras did not demand that Steinbrenner dismiss Cashman or Boone. Instead, he asked whether the organization was willing to reassess what it does when the championship outcome keeps falling short.
The agent acknowledged the work the Yankees have done well before presenting the central challenge to an ownership group that has continued to back its baseball operations leadership.
“I can tell you that they’ve done a lot of right things, but on the other side of it is, I have to tell you, is that have they achieved what they want to achieve?” Boras said. “And you know what? The group of people they have, the ownership they have, they should achieve what they want to achieve, and I’m sure that they have to look at that every day and say, ‘I have to do more, or I have to do different.’”
Boras followed with a sharper point about the need for genuine change rather than another winter of familiar decisions.
“But the one thing I can’t do is I just can’t repeat what I’ve been doing,” Boras said.
The Yankees won 93 games in 2026 but lost the American League Division Series to Tampa Bay in a three-game sweep. The Rays finished the series with a 4-3 win at Yankee Stadium, extending New York’s title drought.
Steinbrenner has nevertheless kept Boone, who is under contract for 2027, and continued to support Cashman.
Boras’ message collides with the Cashman-Boone continuity plan
Boone is returning for his 10th season as manager. Cashman has been the Yankees’ general manager since 1998.
Steinbrenner identified the offense as a major reason for the playoff disappointment. New York’s search for improvement includes second base, third base and a relief corps that Cashman has called his biggest offseason priority.
Anthony Volpe, once the everyday shortstop, returned from Triple-A in September and showed he could contribute at second and third base.
Boras has a direct connection to that development. Volpe sought his advice during a difficult 2026 season, adjusted his approach in the minors and later joined Boras’ agency. He hit .265 over the closing stretch described in the reporting and returned to the postseason lineup.
Volpe’s turnaround shows the value of changing an approach.
Aaron Judge’s all-in demand gives Boras’ warning added urgency
Judge issued his own challenge after the elimination against Tampa Bay. The captain said a winning record and another postseason berth could not substitute for the championship he re-signed with New York to pursue.
He called on the Yankees to close every obvious gap in the roster and personnel rather than accept another season that ends short of the World Series.
“We’re the Yankees,” Judge said. “I feel like they should go all in and do what they need to do and find. If we’ve got holes, if it’s finding certain players or personnel, whatever we need, you’ve got to go out there and get it.”
Judge also rejected the notion that regularly assembling a competitive team satisfies the franchise’s ambitions.
“They give us a winning team every single year, but that’s not good enough here in New York. We’re the Yankees. You’ve got to go out there and chase championships and go all in every year,” Judge said.
Judge and Boras independently challenged the gap between the Yankees’ championship standard and their results.
Smaller markets erode Yankees’ spending advantage
Boras also identified a structural change in baseball. More clubs can access outside investment, sharpen development systems and compete without matching the Yankees’ payroll dollar for dollar.
The Yankees carried a competitive-balance-tax payroll of roughly $336 million in 2026, third highest in MLB, yet their season ended before the league championship series.
Boras argued that clubs in smaller markets have found new ways to challenge traditional powers as capital moves into baseball. New York therefore needs better decisions, not just more expensive ones.
Tampa Bay eliminated the Yankees, and Milwaukee ultimately claimed the World Series, showing that the richest teams do not control the championship path.
Steinbrenner’s salary-cap stance adds a financial conflict
The approaching labor deadline complicates the Yankees‘ response. The collective bargaining agreement expires Dec. 1, with a lockout expected as owners seek a salary cap and players resist it.
Boras has openly opposed a cap. Steinbrenner, a member of MLB’s labor policy committee, has said he supports the owners’ bargaining proposals, which include a cap and salary floor.
Steinbrenner backs rules that could narrow the Yankees’ financial advantage just as Boras calls for greater competitiveness.
Cashman has said he is conducting offseason business under the budget Steinbrenner has provided. With the bullpen and lineup still unsettled, Boras’ warning now hangs over the decisions the Yankees make before the labor deadline.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
