Yankees-Mets Stroman swap for infielder in sight as Queens scramble for pitching help

New York Yankees' pitcher Marcus Stroman reacts to fans at Yankee Stadium during a game in May 2024.
Bryan Miller
Esteban Quiñones
Tuesday February 18, 2025

Table of Contents

The baseball landscape in New York could be poised for an intriguing development as the Yankees intensify efforts to move right-hander Marcus Stroman and his $18.5 million 2025 salary. With spring training underway, an unexpected opportunity has materialized following developments in Queens, where the Mets find themselves grappling with sudden rotation uncertainty. This situation has sparked speculation about a potential rare cross-town transaction between the rival franchises.

Mets confronting pitching predicament

The Mets’ rotation depth has encountered a significant setback with the news that right-handed veteran Frankie Montas has been forced to cease throwing activities due to a severe lat strain. New York Post correspondent Mike Puma reports that Montas faces an extended absence of six to eight weeks minimum, creating an urgent void in the Mets’ already thin pitching arsenal.

This development has elevated the Mets’ need for an established major league starter to critical status, positioning Stroman as a compelling acquisition target. His previous successful stint with the organization adds an intriguing dimension to the possibility, as he could provide immediate stability and veteran leadership to their compromised rotation.

Exploring the Baty factor in Yankees-Mets trade

brett-baty-mets-yankees
AP

Industry sources suggest a potential framework centered around infielder Brett Baty moving to the Bronx in exchange for Stroman. Baty, once a highly-touted first-round selection, has faced challenges establishing himself in the Mets’ regular lineup. His 2024 campaign began with promise as the team’s starting third baseman, but a May demotion in favor of Mark Vientos altered his trajectory.

Baty’s major league statistics tell a story of adjustment, reflected in a .229/.306/.327 slash line with four home runs across 50 games last season. However, his Triple-A performance presents a more optimistic outlook, featuring a robust .252/.349/.504 line, accompanied by an impressive .853 OPS and 16 home runs in 62 appearances. With Pete Alonso entrenched at first base and Vientos seemingly securing third base duties, Baty’s opportunities for regular playing time in Queens appear limited.

From the Yankees‘ perspective, acquiring Baty could address their ongoing search for infield depth while potentially solving their third base equation. The 25-year-old’s offensive ceiling remains intriguing, particularly given the position’s recent productivity challenges.

Potential homecoming narrative

Pitcher Marcus Stroman is reportedly interested to join the Yankees in 2024.
newsday

A trade would represent a full-circle moment for Stroman, who first joined the Mets via trade in 2019 and later returned for the 2021 season. His previous Queens tenure proved successful, highlighted by a commendable 3.21 ERA across 44 starts, demonstrating his ability to thrive in the market’s unique pressures.

Currently, Stroman finds himself in a precarious position as the Yankees’ sixth rotation option. His substantial salary appears misaligned with a potential spot starter role, and his firm stance against bullpen duties further complicates his fit within the team’s plans.

Analyzing next steps

While no immediate transaction appears imminent, the Yankees may find themselves well-positioned to initiate discussions with the Mets, capitalizing on their pressing need for rotation reinforcement. The feasibility of agreement terms remains uncertain, but Stroman’s availability presents an opportune solution to the Mets’ current challenges.

As spring training activities intensify, both organizations face crucial roster decisions. The Yankees could potentially achieve financial flexibility while adding a promising infield prospect, while the Mets could secure an experienced starter to stabilize their rotation.

The possibility of a rare cross-borough transaction looms large over the New York baseball scene. Should circumstances align favorably, Marcus Stroman might soon find himself making an unexpected return to familiar territory in Queens, marking a unique chapter in the city’s baseball narrative.

The potential deal underscores the evolving dynamics of modern baseball, where traditional rivalry boundaries occasionally yield practical roster management and mutual benefit. As both teams navigate their respective challenges, this developing situation exemplifies how unexpected circumstances can create opportunities for creative solutions in the ever-changing landscape of Major League Baseball.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

1 2 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Brian Goley

lol, no.

1
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Join the Pinstripes Nation!

Your Daily Dose of Yankees Magic Delivered to Your Inbox.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Don't Miss Any of the Latest Yankees News, Rumors, and Exclusive Offers!