Justin Verlander to Yankees: A logical fit or just knee-jerk speculation?

Follow Us

The New York Yankees are no strangers to chasing marquee names during the offseason, and this year might be no different. According to Bleacher Report’s Zachary D. Rymer, future Hall of Famer Justin Verlander could land in the Bronx for the 2025 season with a predicted $15-million deal.

“Speaking of fellow Hall of Famers who stared mortality in the face this year, Verlander began 2024 on the IL and never got into a groove after he returned. His fastball (93.5 mph) and contact rate (81.0 percent) both took turns for the worse,” he wrote. “The righty nonetheless believes he has ‘a lot more to give.'”

This prediction has sparked curiosity among fans and analysts alike, as the Yankees continue to evaluate their options to bolster their starting rotation.

Verlander’s legacy ofexcellence

Justin Verlander’s resume is nothing short of legendary. With two World Series championships, three Cy Young Awards, and the 2011 American League MVP under his belt, he has established himself as one of the best pitchers of his generation. Over his illustrious career, the ace has earned nine All-Star selections and led the league in wins multiple times. Despite turning 42 in February, Verlander’s name still carries significant weight in the baseball world. His ability to perform under the spotlight makes him a tantalizing option for a franchise that demands success on the grandest stage.

However, Verlander faced setbacks in the 2024 season, starting the year on the injured list and struggling to find his rhythm upon return. Notably, his fastball velocity decreased to an average of 93.5 mph, and his contact rate increased to 81.0%, indicating potential declines in performance. However, Verlander has expressed confidence in his ability to continue contributing at a high level.

Why the Yankees?

Rymer’s prediction stems from the Yankees’ clear need to strengthen their rotation. With Gerrit Cole leading the staff and Carlos Rodon expected to bounce back in 2025, the addition of Verlander could provide the veteran depth and postseason experience that the Yankees have been lacking in recent years.

The Yankees are in need of experienced pitching to enhance their rotation. Verlander’s extensive postseason experience and leadership qualities could provide valuable depth. Analysts suggest that a one-year, $15 million contract could be a feasible arrangement, balancing the risk associated with his age and recent injuries against his potential upside. Such an arrangement would give New York flexibility while providing Verlander another shot at October glory in baseball’s biggest market.

Beyond pure performance metrics, Verlander’s potential impact on the Yankees’ younger arms cannot be overlooked. His experience in navigating the pressures of a pennant race and adapting his approach as velocity naturally declines could prove invaluable to the next generation of Yankee pitchers.

The Yankees are known for their aggressive approach in free agency, and Verlander’s pedigree fits their brand of excellence. Signing him would not only bolster the rotation but also send a message that the Yankees are serious about contending in 2025.

Rymer’s suggestion of Verlander to the Yankees highlights the team’s urgency to address their pitching needs. The Yankees fell short in 2024, and their ability to compete in the postseason hinges on a strong and consistent rotation. Adding Verlander could provide a short-term solution with long-term ripple effects, offering the Yankees a chance to capitalize on his experience while grooming their next generation of pitchers.

Concerns persist after 2024 output

While Verlander’s accolades are impressive, his recent seasons raise questions. In 2024, he struggled with injuries and a dip in velocity, with his fastball averaging 93.5 mph—lower than his career norms. Additionally, his contact rate increased to 81.0%, hinting at declining dominance. Despite these challenges, Verlander still managed to display moments of brilliance, showcasing his ability to adapt and perform.

“I do feel like I have a lot more to give pitching-wise,” the pitcher said. “This year was a tough year, learned a lot from it. Obviously, I talked to you guys about how I was feeling coming back [from a neck injury] and how I needed to push the issue a bit.”

The way ahead

The Yankees would need to weigh the potential benefits of adding Verlander against the risks associated with his age and recent injuries. However, Verlander’s extensive postseason experience and track record of success make him an enticing option. If healthy, he could slot into the rotation as a reliable arm, alleviating pressure on the younger pitchers and serving as a mentor.

While the idea of Justin Verlander in pinstripes is still speculative, Rymer’s prediction underscores a logical fit between the pitcher and the Yankees. As the offseason progresses, the Yankees will need to decide whether to take a chance on a future Hall of Famer who could bring leadership, depth, and postseason prowess to their roster. For now, fans can only wait and wonder if Verlander will indeed find a new chapter in his storied career in the Bronx.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us