Host feels Yankees primed for AL dominance, ex-GM expects more disappointment

Suzyn waldman is interviewing Oswaldo Cabrera of the New York Yankees after his first major league home run on September 11, 2022.

Table of Contents

Amidst swirling rumors about the Yankees potentially concluding their offseason without significant additions beyond potential bullpen pieces, analyst BT maintains confidence in the team’s ability to end their decade-long championship drought.

BT boldly asserts that the Yankees are the current frontrunners in the American League, crediting their strengthened position to internal improvements and a perceived weakening of the overall league. While acknowledging the limited impact of acquiring Marcus Stroman alone amid rotation concerns, he highlights the trade deadline as a readily available avenue for adjustments come July.

BT foresees Yankees pushing for championship

Acknowledging the possibility of no further substantial acquisitions this winter, BT emphasizes the importance of the timing of such a decision. While expressing a hint of disappointment at the potential deviation from anticipated moves, he underscores the ongoing nature of the offseason, leaving room for potential future transactions.

Yankees pitcher Carlos Rodon with manager Aaron Boone during the 2023 season.

Instead of immediate, impactful signings, BT envisions a strategic approach fueled by a robust trade market. He suggests that the Yankees already possess sufficient resources to start the season strongly, with opportunities for further adjustments mid-season. Should Carlos Rodon‘s performance mirror his recent struggles, BT sees the trade deadline as the ideal time to explore alternative pitching options.

The inconsistency of Rodon remains the biggest concern in the starting rotation. However, a return to his dominant 2022 form would undoubtedly strengthen BT’s confidence in the Yankees’ potential return to the World Series. He even predicts a potential 100-win season with a peak-performing Rodon, paving the way for a long-awaited championship run.

Ex-New York GM dismisses Yankees rebuild

As the New York Yankees undergo a major overhaul of their outfield this offseason, former GM Jim Duquette has expressed skepticism about their competitiveness in 2024. Appearing on the “Foul Territory” show, Duquette cast doubt on the Yankees’ lineup, suggesting it falls short of American League East contender status despite recent acquisitions.

Following a disappointing 82-80 season and playoff miss in 2023, the Yankees focused on outfield reinforcements after top prospect Jasson Domínguez underwent Tommy John surgery. General manager Brian Cashman acknowledged the need for “two outfielders,” particularly a center fielder and preferably a left-handed bat.

During the Winter Meetings, the Yankees executed two significant trades to address their outfield needs. The headline deal brought Juan Soto and Trent Grisham from the Padres in exchange for four pitchers and catcher Kyle Higashioka. Additionally, Alex Verdugo arrived from the Red Sox in a separate trade. To strengthen the rotation, the team signed free agent Marcus Stroman to a two-year, $37 million deal.

Despite these moves, Duquette remains unconvinced. He believes the current roster is projected to be a third-place team in the American League East, causing concern among fans anticipating a championship push.

Duquette acknowledged areas requiring further action for the Yankees to truly contend. He emphasized the need for additional depth in the rotation, expressing concerns about the current crop of pitchers being reliant on health. Duquette also highlighted the necessity for bullpen help, suggesting potential targets like Hector Neris and Josh Hader.

Recognizing the budgetary constraints with the Yankees‘ substantial $293.2 million payroll, currently second in MLB, and projected $48.4 million competitive balance tax payment, Duquette proposed strategic signings to address bullpen needs.


The debate surrounding the Yankees’ offseason continues. While some point to the addition of elite talent like Soto and Grisham, others question the depth sacrificed and express reservations about the overall balance of the roster. Duquette’s skepticism adds another layer to the discussion, casting doubt on whether their revamped outfield will be enough to propel them back to the postseason. However, his focus on the remaining needs in the rotation and bullpen also highlights the critical areas where further action is necessary for the Yankees to truly solidify their championship aspirations.

The upcoming season will ultimately reveal the effectiveness of the Yankees’ revamped roster. Whether Duquette’s prediction holds true or the Yankees defy expectations remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: the pressure on Brian Cashman and his team to deliver a championship has never been higher.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Related posts:

2 thoughts on “Host feels Yankees primed for AL dominance, ex-GM expects more disappointment

  1. The Yankees will do better than Duquette’s predictions. They made some significant improvements, but definitely should have done more. As good as Soto can be, there is no guarantee he will re-sign with the Yankees. I think Cody Bellinger might have met more needs in terms of defense and position flexibility and keeping Judge from centerfield. Also a backup for Rizzo possibly this year and more likely next year. I wonder if some combinaton of Verdugo (only if they had gotten Belinger), Peraza or Torres and a minor leaguer could have landed another starter

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join the Pinstripes Nation!

Your Daily Dose of Yankees Magic Delivered to Your Inbox

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Don't Miss Any of the Latest Yankees News, Rumors, and Exclusive Offers!