Gerrit Cole explains why staying with the Yankees was never in doubt


Amanda Paula
More Stories By Amanda Paula
- Mother’s Day: How Anthony Volpe’s mom molded him into a Yankee phenom
- Yankees eye late move: Five right-handed bats they could add before Opening Day
- Is Dominic Smith real cause of Yankees’ reluctance to re-sign Verdugo?
- Bauer’s Trump theory gets sharp rebuttal from Yankees’ Michael Kay
- Yankees injury update: Schmidt uncertain, Paul still zero, two relievers face concerns
Table of Contents
Gerrit Cole might be the most entertaining voice in the Yankees‘ clubhouse. During his second spring training press conference on Wednesday, he addressed a topic that had stirred debate among fans—his contract opt-out situation.
Gerrit Cole made it clear that his plan was always to remain with the Yankees: “My intention wasn’t to do anything other than stay.”
The Opt-Out clause and contractual dynamics
Gerrit Cole’s original contract with the Yankees, signed in December 2019, was a landmark nine-year, $324 million deal, setting a record for the largest contract ever awarded to a pitcher at that time. This agreement included an opt-out clause after the 2024 season, allowing Cole the option to enter free agency. To retain him, the Yankees held the right to add an additional year at $36 million, extending the contract through 2029. citeturn0search0
In November 2024, Cole exercised his opt-out clause, a move that initiated a two-day window for the Yankees to respond. After deliberation, both parties agreed to continue under the existing contract terms, keeping Cole with the team through 2028 without the additional year. General Manager Brian Cashman emphasized the mutual desire to maintain the relationship, stating, “We wanted our player and our ace back, and he certainly didn’t want to go either.”
Gerrit Cole’s performance and leadership

Despite facing challenges in the 2024 season due to elbow issues that delayed his debut until June, Gerrit Cole demonstrated resilience and excellence upon his return. He made 17 starts, achieving an 8-5 record with a 3.41 ERA, and recorded 99 strikeouts over 95 innings. His postseason performance was particularly notable, with a 2.17 ERA across five starts.
Beyond his on-field achievements, Gerrit Cole has emerged as a pivotal leader within the Yankees’ clubhouse. His dedication to mentoring teammates and fostering a culture of hard work and discipline has been widely recognized. Reflecting on his role, Cole has expressed a commitment to exemplifying virtues such as perseverance and respectfulness, aiming to set a positive example for both his teammates and his young sons.
Gerrit Cole’s choice to remain with the Yankees underscores his deep connection to the organization and his belief in the team’s potential for future success. By forgoing the opt-out opportunity, he has reaffirmed his dedication to contributing to the Yankees’ pursuit of championships in the coming years.
This decision not only solidifies the Yankees’ starting rotation but also reinforces the leadership core within the clubhouse, with Gerrit Cole continuing to play a central role in guiding and inspiring his teammates.
As the Yankees prepare for the upcoming season, Gerrit Cole’s steadfast commitment and proven track record serve as a cornerstone for the team’s aspirations, reflecting a shared vision of excellence and a collective drive toward achieving their ultimate goals.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
- Categories: Gerrit Cole, News
- Tags: gerrit cole, New York Yankees
