Enmity vs. emotion: Who Yankees fans should cheer in Dodgers-Blue Jays duel

Follow Us

NEW YORK — Yankees fans face an unusual dilemma this October. For the first time in franchise history, the Bronx faithful must decide whether to root for their bitter rival, the Toronto Blue Jays, or back the Los Angeles Dodgers, a club that shares New York’s big-market reputation. At the center of it all stands Yankees legend Don Mattingly, who is finally on baseball’s biggest stage as Toronto’s manager.

The New York Post summed up the conflict in three words on October 24: “Do it for Donnie.” It captured the debate that has divided Yankees fans of different generations.

Why Dodgers fit the Yankees fan code

Normally, the Yankees fan base follows a clear postseason script. Always root against Boston. Avoid supporting division rivals. Prefer National League teams to succeed over American League opponents.

The Dodgers fit this formula perfectly. Los Angeles is a powerhouse franchise, but their success doesn’t hurt New York in the standings. They’re not a threat to the Yankees’ playoff path, and a Dodgers championship sends a message to Hal Steinbrenner and Brian Cashman that aggressive spending and bold moves pay off.

Yankees fans also appreciate the distance. The Dodgers rivalry with New York feels like a relic of the Brooklyn days. The last World Series between the teams was in 1981. For modern Yankees fans, beating Toronto in the AL East feels far more urgent than revisiting the Yankees-Dodgers nostalgia.

Why Toronto feels impossible to support

The Blue Jays represent a problem much closer to home. Toronto is a direct rival, competing for the same division title, the same Wild Card berths, and even some of the same free agents. Yankees fans just watched their season end at the hands of the Blue Jays in the Division Series, making the idea of cheering for Toronto feel like betrayal.

“It reminds me of some of those Giants fans last season who they would be the ones that say, ‘I’m not rooting for the Eagles to win the Super Bowl. I’m rooting for Saquon,’” Brandon London said on Back Page Banter. “Absolutely not. I went full Tiki Barber. Saquon was dead to me because he was with the Eagles.”

For many Yankees fans, that comparison rings true. You can’t separate the rival from the person. Supporting Toronto feels like breaking the code.

The unwritten rules Yankees fans live by

Being a Yankees fan has always meant following certain unwritten rules. Never cheer for Boston. Never celebrate Houston. Never hand a rival like Toronto the satisfaction of your support.

“If you’re a Yankees fan, there’s a code,” London added. “And no matter how old you are or how old you were when the Yankees glory days were back in your time, the code is the code. It’s New York or nowhere.”

That loyalty has carried Yankees fans through countless Octobers without a title. It’s a clear guideline. Support underdogs against rivals. Pull for National League teams when the Yankees are eliminated. Above all, don’t root for division opponents.

Yet Don Mattingly complicates the matter. The beloved captain never reached the World Series in his 14-year career in pinstripes. Now he has his shot, only it’s with Toronto.

Mattingly factor puts hearts against heads

Mattingly’s legacy with the Yankees is undeniable. A six-time All-Star, nine-time Gold Glove winner, and 1985 MVP, his No. 23 is enshrined in Monument Park. He carried the Yankees during lean years but never experienced October glory.

Now, at 64, he is finally in the World Series. But it comes as the Blue Jays’ manager, the same team that ended the Yankees’ playoff run weeks ago.

“Yankees fans asking for a friend here. How you going to be watching this World Series?” London asked. “Is it still we’re going to live by the code, New York or nowhere? Or are you going to root for your divisional rival who knocked you out of the postseason so Donnie Baseball can get his first ring?”

It’s a choice between honoring a Yankees icon and sticking to the rivalry rules. For many, it feels like an impossible question.

Strategy adds another layer

Beyond emotion, some Yankees fans look at strategy. If the Blue Jays win the World Series, it could embolden Toronto’s front office and make the club more attractive to future free agents. A championship would strengthen the Jays’ position in the AL East, creating an even bigger obstacle for New York.

Others argue the opposite — that a title could lead to complacency. Front offices sometimes stand pat after success, while failure often drives teams to improve aggressively.

There’s also the Vladimir Guerrero Jr. factor. Yankees fans dream of Guerrero in pinstripes one day. Watching him win a championship in Toronto might deepen his ties there and close the door on that possibility.

A generational split among Yankees fans

Older Yankees fans who grew up watching Mattingly find it hardest to separate their loyalty. They remember his smooth swing, his leadership, and his loyalty to the franchise during years when titles seemed far away. For them, Mattingly’s moment feels personal.

Younger fans don’t have the same attachment. They know him as a former Marlins manager or now as Toronto’s leader. For that group, the rivalry trumps nostalgia. As London joked: “Young Yankees fans, get on ChatGPT and ask who this guy is.”

The debate has played out across social media. Some Yankees fans post “Do it for Donnie.” Others insist on “anybody but Toronto.” The divide reflects a generational difference in how Yankees loyalty is defined.

Respect without support

The reality for many Yankees fans may lie in the middle. They can respect Mattingly’s accomplishment without rooting for Toronto. They can acknowledge his journey while refusing to celebrate Blue Jays success.

Baseball history has delivered these dilemmas before. Luis Gonzalez ended the Yankees dynasty in 2001 as a Diamondback. David Cone and Johnny Damon won championships with Boston. Fans found ways to honor individuals while maintaining their loyalty to New York.

Mattingly deserves the recognition. His career with the Yankees earned him that. But cheering for the Blue Jays — especially after they eliminated New York — is likely a bridge too far.

The Bronx will follow its code. Respect Donnie Baseball. Celebrate his moment. But when Toronto takes the field, Yankees fans will remember the rule that has never changed: New York or nowhere.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us