Criticism grows as Yankees rookie Will Warren struggles in crucial outing


Amanda Paula
More Stories By Amanda Paula
- Mother’s Day: How Anthony Volpe’s mom molded him into a Yankee phenom
- How Yankees heart transplant sparked Trump nominee’s controversial rise
- With Gerrit Cole Out, Yankees turn to Carlos Rodon for Opening Day start
- Yankees turned down several trade requests for Will Warren, insider reveals
- Are the Yankees willing to do a pitching trade with the Phillies?
Table of Contents
New York Yankees rookie pitcher Will Warren found himself at the center of controversy following a disastrous performance in the team’s 9-2 loss to the Colorado Rockies at Yankee Stadium on Saturday. The game, which coincided with the team’s Old-Timers’ Day celebration, quickly turned sour for both Warren and Yankees fans, who didn’t hold back in their criticism.
Will Warren, a 25-year-old right-hander, was called up just days earlier to help fill the gap left by the injured Luis Gil. Despite the high hopes placed on him, Warren struggled mightily against the Rockies, giving up six runs—five of them earned—over just three innings. His outing was marked by two balks and a string of two-out hits, including a two-run double by Nolan Jones in a particularly rough third inning.
Fans react to Will Warren’s struggles
The loss dropped Will Warren to 0-2 in his brief MLB career and pushed his ERA to a staggering 9.68 over 17.2 innings. His struggles weren’t limited to the majors; Warren had also posted a 6.11 ERA in Triple-A this season, raising questions about his readiness for the big leagues.
Yankees fans, already frustrated by the team’s inconsistent season, were quick to express their disappointment on social media. Comments ranged from calls for Warren’s demotion to more measured takes suggesting he needs more time to develop in the minors.
“Will Warren doesn’t belong on an MLB roster,” tweeted one user, Pinstripes Jungle. “Guy can’t pitch, time to try someone else.”
Warren doesn't belong on an MLB roster. Guy can't pitch, time to try someone else.
— ChefYankeesD (71-50) (@PinstripeJungle) August 25, 2024
Will Warren if the Yankees starting rotation wasn’t cursed with injuries pic.twitter.com/FwXKX2AA4S
— Freddie🫡 (@YankeesSzn99) August 24, 2024
I like Will Warren and think his stuff is really good he just needs a bit more time to develop pic.twitter.com/tISlBl9Sjc
— Aiden Béchamps (@ABechamps) August 24, 2024
Will Warren should never pitch again in the majors for the Yankees.
— Bronx Bombers Tonight (@BombersTonight) August 24, 2024
Another fan, Aiden Béchamps, offered a more tempered perspective: “I like Will Warren and think his stuff is really good. He just needs a bit more time to develop.”
Yankees’ coaching staff responds

The Yankees’ coaching staff, however, remains somewhat optimistic. Manager Aaron Boone acknowledged Warren’s struggles but hinted that the team might still give him another shot in the rotation.
“I think Will is certainly a candidate to take that next one,” Boone said. “We feel like he’s capable; it’s just a game of execution.”
"I think Will's certainly a candidate to take that next one. We feel like he's capable, it's just a game of execution."
— Yankees Videos (@snyyankees) August 24, 2024
Aaron Boone was asked if the Yankees are considering going with someone besides Will Warren for the next turn through the rotation: pic.twitter.com/ewEIWBhk3Q
The Yankees’ loss on Saturday was particularly tough for fans, as it marred what was supposed to be a celebratory day at the ballpark. The Old-Timers’ Day ceremony had honored the 15th anniversary of the Yankees’ 2009 championship, with team legends like Derek Jeter and Mariano Rivera in attendance. However, the lopsided defeat dampened the mood, leaving fans wondering about the team’s future and Warren’s role in it.
As the Yankees look to clinch a series victory on Sunday, questions surrounding Warren’s place in the rotation will likely continue to be a topic of heated debate among the fanbase. For now, the young pitcher remains a symbol of the challenges facing a Yankees team that has struggled to find consistency in 2024.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
- Categories: Fan Reactions, News, Off The Field, Will Warren
- Tags: New York Yankees, will warren
Related posts:

Too many dumbasses commenting negatively based on emotion( zero thinking). Just wish some of them would get a taste of reality should their employer fire their crazy asses should they do one thing of which their employer thought could be done more effectively.