NEW YORK — For most of his time in pinstripes, the question about Jonathan Loaisiga was never talent. It was whether he could stay on the mound.
In 2026, pitching more than 2,000 miles from the Bronx, he finally answered it.
The right-hander made a career-high 67 appearances for the Arizona Diamondbacks and posted a 2.42 ERA over 67 innings. That was more games than he pitched for the Yankees in 2023, 2024 and 2025 combined.
Now the Yankees, the team that let him walk a year ago, want him back. The two sides, though, are nowhere near each other on what a reunion should look like.
The Yankees have made Loaisiga a formal offer, believed to be a one-year deal, NJ.com’s Randy Miller reported Tuesday. Loaisiga, 32, is seeking a three-year contract in the $18 million to $20 million range.
Inside the offer and the ask
The exact value of the Yankees’ proposal has not been disclosed. It is believed to top the one-year, $5 million offer from Arizona, which had been his only other offer.
The Los Angeles Dodgers, New York Mets and Philadelphia Phillies have also shown interest. None of the three had made an offer, according to NJ.com.
Loaisiga’s push for multiple years goes beyond money. He has eight years and 22 days of major league service time. Ten years qualifies a player for a full MLB pension.
Under the current rules, that full pension pays $290,000 a year starting at age 62. Reduced payments can begin as early as 45.
Why two years matters
The pension goal explains why a one-year offer, even a raise from Arizona’s, does not close the deal. A source close to the pitcher laid out that priority to NJ.com.
“Two years is important to him because he wants to secure the 10 years,” the source said.
Timing is the other pressure point. The collective bargaining agreement expires Dec. 1, and a work stoppage is widely expected to follow. Loaisiga wants to sign before then, and so do the Yankees, according to the same source.
“I know they want him to sign before the lockout,” the source said.
The numbers behind the gap
The figures on each side tell the story of how far apart the talks are.
Loaisiga’s ask works out to roughly $6 million to $6.7 million per season. That is modest for a reliever coming off a 2.42 ERA. The sticking point is the length, not the yearly rate.
His entire three-year ask is still smaller than what the Yankees committed to one reliever this week. Closer David Bednar accepted a one-year, $23.15 million qualifying offer Tuesday. That single season is worth more than Loaisiga’s requested three.
Loaisiga’s price has also climbed fast. He earned a $1.5 million major league salary in 2026 after signing a minor league deal with Arizona in January. His three-year request is 12 to 13 times that figure.
The durability turnaround is the reason. Loaisiga pitched in just 50 games over his final three seasons in New York. He went on the injured list 10 times as a Yankee, according to NJ.com, and a flexor strain ended his 2025 season in August.
In Arizona, he stayed on the field and kept hitters off balance. He struck out 48 and walked 13, finished with a 1.03 WHIP and went 7-3, according to CBS Sports. Statcast data showed a sinker that averaged about 98 mph, a 3.5% barrel rate and a 55.8% ground-ball rate, in the 95th percentile.
What it means for the Yankees bullpen
The Yankees entered the offseason with six free-agent relievers: Bednar, Tim Hill, John Schreiber, Ryan Yarbrough, Paul Blackburn and Michael Fulmer.
Two of those holes are now filled. Bednar returned on the qualifying offer, and Hill agreed to a one-year, $2.25 million deal last weekend.
The rest of the bullpen still needs work. Before Bednar’s decision, left-hander Brent Headrick was the only high-leverage arm under contract for 2027.
Loaisiga knows the Yankees‘ system well. He pitched for New York from 2018 to 2025, posting a 3.54 ERA over 249 1/3 innings. His best year in the Bronx came in 2021, when he went 9-4 with a 2.17 ERA in 57 outings.
The Yankees declined his $5 million club option for 2026 last November, making him a free agent. He then chose Arizona, a warm-weather city in the pitcher-friendly NL West, for a chance at a full season.
That bet paid off. It also changed his leverage.
With the Dec. 1 deadline less than two weeks away, both sides have reason to move. Whether either will bridge the difference before baseball’s calendar freezes remains the open question.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.


















