Yankees’ Gerrit Cole wins poll for first-half AL Cy Young, fan reactions divided

Yankees ace Gerrit Cole has emerged as the best pitcher to win the mid-season Cy Young Award in an MLB fans’ poll conducted by FOX Sports. The announcement was made on Twitter by FOX Sports reads, “We asked, and you voted… MLB on FOX fans picked Gerrit Cole as the 2023 mid-season AL Cy Young.”  It generated excitement among fans and sparked debate about Cole’s outstanding performance.

We asked and you voted…

MLB on FOX fans picked Gerrit Cole as the 2023 midseason AL Cy Young 🔥 pic.twitter.com/Fsfzy9btXj

— FOX Sports: MLB (@MLBONFOX) July 13, 2023

The initial half of the 2023 MLB season was filled with excitement and intrigue. It witnessed some teams surpassing expectations while others faltered. Similarly, players faced scrutiny based on their performances. As fans passionately debated the top performers in each division, Gerrit Cole, who garnered the most votes and emerged as the fan-favorite winner, stands out.

Due to his exceptional displays on the mound, the Yankees‘ star pitcher claimed the prestigious Mid-Season AL Cy Young Award. Nonetheless, the decision was not without its challenges. While numerous fans supported and validated the outcome, there were also those who held differing opinions and voiced their disagreements.

Gerrit Cole continues to sparkle despite gloomy show by the Yankees

Despite the New York Yankees’ struggles as a team, Gerrit Cole continued to demonstrate his brilliance. While his team struggled with a depleted roster and limited pitching options, Cole stood out on the mound. In his 19 starts this season, he achieved an impressive record of nine wins and two losses. With a WHIP of 1.120, an ERA of 2.85, and a remarkable 123 strikeouts, Cole showcased his dominance and skill.

With his exceptional performances, Gerrit Cole earned a well-deserved spot on the All-Star team. This achievement serves as a significant milestone for the Yankees ace, especially considering the initial criticism he faced. The support from fans reflects their recognition of his talent and validates the substantial nine-year, $324 million contract he signed. It signifies the confidence and belief in Gerrit Cole’s abilities to deliver outstanding results for the Yankees.

While the outcome was not surprising, there were some fans who voiced their disapproval of the result. However, the majority of social media buzz surrounding the announcement was filled with congratulations and praises for Gerrit Cole’s achievement.

Fans remain divided over Gerrit Cole’s win

The selection of Gerrit Cole for the mid-season award has sparked a division among fans within the baseball community. While many supporters are pleased with his win, others have voiced their opinion that pitchers like Framber Valdez were more deserving of the accolade.

pic.twitter.com/Lb4TFuPtaG

— Sad New York Fan (Fire Cashman) (@SadNYGuy) July 13, 2023

pic.twitter.com/hmvWGFI50u

— Scott BlueJaysAlways (@BluejaysAlways) July 13, 2023

ACE

— Leo Saperstein (@saperstein21) July 13, 2023

There are a few dissenting viewpoints from the prevailing consensus.

The divergence in fan opinion and preferences is evident. While Gerrit Cole’s victory in the mid-season award is significant, his ultimate success at the end of the season will depend on his ability to maintain consistency and outperform his competitors.

Can Gerrit Cole sustain his performance and diminish the criticism surrounding him? What are your thoughts on this matter? Feel free to share your opinions in the comments section!