NEW YORK — If the Yankees are weighing a reunion with Jazz Chisholm Jr., the fans have a clear message for them.
Nearly nine out of every 10 respondents in a Pinstripes Nation X poll opposed bringing the free-agent second baseman back for another season, even as a reunion remains possible.
Facebook comments also leaned against a 2027 reunion, although the divide was narrower.
The poll, conducted by Pinstripes Nation, reflects the opinions of participating readers, but coul be seen as the broader sentiment of Yankees fan base.
The rumor that forces fans to speak out
The Athletic’s Jim Bowden was the first to claim about the possibility of a reunion between the Yankees and Chisholm.
“The Yankees have also been connected with second basemen Brandon Lowe and Luis Arraez, and the door has not been shut on a reunion with Jazz Chisholm Jr. just yet,” he wrote.
New York did not extend Chisholm the $23.15 million qualifying offer by the Nov. 2 deadline. The decision lets him explore free agency without draft-pick compensation attached to his departure. The club did make that offer to closer David Bednar.
The decision does not prevent another contract with Chisholm, but a Yankees reunion has not been announced or formally established by the poll.
“This is where I want to be,” Chisholm said after the postseason, expressing a desire to remain with the Yankees.
A Chisholm reunion could benefit the Yankees if he recaptures his 2025 All-Star form. However, his 2026 regression, attitude concerns and .537 career playoff OPS strengthen the case for moving on.
But Yankees fan poll die-hard against Chisholm return
For many Yankees fans opposed to a reunion, the objection was less about talent than about results. Facebook commenter Arnold Chin summed up that view:
“No , we tried it with him , no championship, let’s move on”
Others pointed to fit and consistency, and Chisholm’s 2026 season gave skeptics plenty to work with. He hit .231 with 19 home runs, 55 RBIs and a .711 OPS over 137 regular-season games. That was a step back from 2025, when he hit a career-high 31 home runs with an .813 OPS.
October did not help his case. Chisholm batted .182 with no home runs in the Yankees’ postseason run and was out of the lineup for Game 3 of the ALDS against the Rays.
Some of the opposition also reflects a broader fatigue with the Yankees running it back with familiar faces. That complaint surfaced again this week after the Yankees reportedly agreed to bring back reliever Tim Hill on a one-year deal.
For many opponents, the issue extends beyond Chisholm’s individual statistics. The Yankees have failed to turn regular-season success into a championship, and a familiar roster could bring familiar frustrations.
Facebook reactions reveal a less lopsided debate
The opposition also appeared in a preliminary review of Facebook comments, although the response was not as overwhelmingly negative as the X poll.
Of 435 comments previously categorized, 287 opposed a reunion, 138 supported one and 10 were unclear or conditional. That is approximately 66% opposed, 32% supportive and 2% unclear among the comments analyzed.
These are comments, not votes or unique respondents. Facebook’s “Most relevant” sorting can omit contributions, and an individual account can comment more than once. The figures should not be combined with the X vote count.
The discussion revealed competing priorities: opponents want the club to move on from a familiar roster, while supporters value Chisholm’s speed and extra-base power.
Chisholm’s production gives supporters a counterargument
The contrast explains why the disagreement is not simply about popularity.
Supporters have a different argument: Chisholm brings speed, power and athleticism that would not necessarily be straightforward to replace. They dangle the possibility of another 30-homer season.
Chisholm hit .231 with 19 home runs, 55 RBIs and 41 stolen bases in 137 games during 2026. His .711 OPS represented a sharp drop from .813 in 2025, when he hit 31 homers and stole 31 bases.
“Absolutely YES! 41 stolen bases and 19 Home runs from a 2nd baseman? Only 3-4 2nd baseman had better numbers last season,” Vince Bennington wrote on Facebook.
His stolen-base figure matches the 41 that CBS Sports credits Chisholm with for 2026. Late in the season, he was one home run shy of the second 20-40 season of his career. He is also still young for a free agent, turning 29 in February.
Backers also questioned what the alternative would be. The second-base free-agent class includes Brandon Lowe, Luis Arraez, Mauricio Dubon and former Yankees infielder Gleyber Torres, and each comes with tradeoffs of his own.
An angry Karen A. Hedden called those supporting his return as “Bananas.” He wrote, “No, maybe the Bananas would want him.”
Fans’ verdict creates a challenge for Cashman
MLB.com reported Nov. 13 that 11 clubs had engaged with Chisholm’s representatives, with Toronto among the teams linked to him. The report indicated a return to the Yankees was considered unlikely, making the fan debate distinct from the club’s actual plans.
The Yankees have internal second-base alternatives, including Anthony Volpe, Jose Caballero and Luis García Jr., while the free-agent market offers other options.
For general manager Brian Cashman, the question is whether Chisholm’s speed, athleticism and rebound potential justify another contract or whether a different second baseman would offer a better fit for 2027.
But Jim @jimg358 pointed out something different, “Jazz has talent but the yanks have a leadership problem and don’t need this kind of problem. Good luck Jazz. We wish you the best.”
What do you think? Leave your comments below.


















