Yankees kids get reality check as ex-prospect bares Cashman’s flawed policy

Follow Us

Rising prospects in the New York Yankees’ minor league system should pay attention to Josh Smith‘s journey. The Texas Rangers infielder was once a promising Yankees farmhand before reality set in. His experience offers a sobering lesson about organizational priorities and player development.

Smith currently ranks among the Rangers’ most valuable contributors. He was previously rated as the Yankees’ No. 14 prospect before his departure. His candid reflection on his time in New York provides insight into the franchise’s approach to prospect management.

“I kind of always figured I would get traded out of there, to be honest with you,” Smith said in an interview with The New York Post. “I just figured if I played well enough, I’d get traded.”

His prediction proved accurate. The Yankees dealt Smith to Texas in July 2021 as part of the blockbuster Joey Gallo acquisition. While the trade generated excitement for bringing a power hitter to the Bronx, the pieces New York surrendered deserve closer examination.

From farmhand to fall classic

Smith’s Yankees career began with significant potential. The organization selected him in the second round from LSU during the 2019 draft. He quickly developed into a contact-oriented infielder with impressive versatility across multiple positions.

The 2020 season’s cancellation due to the pandemic interrupted his development. But Smith returned strong in 2021, batting .320 with three home runs and 12 stolen bases across 49 High-A plate appearances. His performance was trending upward when the trade occurred.

The Yankees possessed a crowded infield prospect pool, including Anthony Volpe and Oswald Peraza. Smith became expendable when the organization prioritized a playoff push. New York packaged him with three other prospects to acquire Gallo from the Rangers.

The transaction proved pivotal for Smith’s career trajectory. Gallo struggled significantly in New York before being traded to the Dodgers the following season. Meanwhile, Smith’s development accelerated with his new organization. He reached the majors with Texas in August 2022 and earned a World Series championship ring just over a year later.

“I loved my time with the Yankees,” Smith said. “I kind of just saw myself not really moving up very fast with them. And I got traded here, and it worked out perfectly.”

A breakout built on versatility

Smith has evolved from a depth player into a cornerstone piece for Texas. His 2024 campaign included nearly 150 games played and a 3.2 bWAR contribution. He demonstrated exceptional defensive flexibility by appearing at shortstop, third base, first base, and all three outfield positions.

His offensive production matched his defensive value. Smith posted a .731 OPS while contributing 13 home runs and 30 doubles. The season culminated with a Silver Slugger Award, confirming Texas’ faith in his abilities when they made the original trade.

Smith has elevated his performance even further in 2025. Entering the series finale against the Yankees at Yankee Stadium, he owns a .285 batting average and .769 OPS. He continues playing multiple positions and frequently leads off against right-handed pitching, demonstrating his increased importance to manager Bruce Bochy’s lineup.

“He’s one of those guys you can plug in anywhere and know you’ll get great effort and results,” Bochy said earlier this week.

Yankees’ loss, Rangers’ gain

The Gallo trade represents a familiar pattern for the Yankees organization. They frequently leverage promising prospects to pursue immediate championship contention. Anthony Volpe has established himself as a Bronx fixture, and Oswald Peraza has gained major league experience. However, Smith’s external success raises questions about organizational talent evaluation.

Smith harbors no apparent resentment toward his former organization. He remains appreciative of the development he received during his time in the Yankees system and maintains relationships with former teammates. However, his observations provide valuable perspective for current prospects navigating the organization.

Smith warned that playing well enough in that system might result in being traded rather than promoted.

His statement reflects the reality of an organization that treats prospects as assets in pursuit of championship windows. Smith’s case demonstrates that sometimes the traded piece becomes more valuable than the acquired player.

A message forthe Yankees’ next generation

Current Yankees prospects should internalize Smith’s experience and prepare accordingly. Strong performance at Double-A or Triple-A doesn’t guarantee a promotion to the Bronx. It might instead generate trade interest from other organizations seeking talent.

This perspective isn’t pessimistic but practical. The Yankees have always balanced internal development with aggressive deadline acquisitions. This approach has produced both championships and constant roster turnover. Even highly-regarded prospects must remain mentally prepared for relocation.

Smith’s success in Texas proves that trades don’t equal failure. They might actually open better opportunities than staying in New York. However, for young players dreaming of wearing pinstripes, the journey often begins in Tampa and ends far from the Bronx spotlight.

No regrets, but plenty to reflect on

Smith has become an integral part of a Rangers team that reached the World Series and could contend again. He’s producing at the plate, displaying excellent plate discipline, and providing valuable positional flexibility. He’s not merely filling roster spots but helping define the team’s character.

The Yankees have moved forward, as they consistently do. But Smith’s performance this week in the Bronx serves as a reminder of what they surrendered and what others should consider.

Whether the Yankees regret that particular transaction remains unclear. One thing is certain: Josh Smith’s career path offers a blueprint for handling baseball’s unpredictable business. Compete fiercely. Stay prepared. Always maximize the next opportunity, even if it’s not in New York.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us