How did a Yankees trade move change their fortune in 1998

As the trade deadline nears, there are many rumors and reports linking the Yankees to multiple big performers in the 2023 season. However, a look back to the 1998 season reveals how an unnamed, mediocre player, Scott Brosius, traded to the Yankees changed their fortune and ultimately carry them to the World Series title.

Following the 1997 season, it became evident that the Yankees’ signing of Kenny Rogers had not lived up to expectations. Rogers, who had joined the team as a free agent in 1996 after an All-Star season, had contributed to the Yankees’ championship victory that year. However, his performance during the regular season was mediocre, and he had a rough outing in the ALCS, lasting only three innings. In the subsequent year, Rogers’ performance declined further, and the negative press surrounding his struggles only added to the disappointment.

Following the season, the Yankees managed to trade Rogers to the Oakland Athletics. In exchange, the Athletics agreed to send a player to be named later, a move that would prove crucial for the Yankees. The player who eventually came to the Yankees as part of the trade turned out to be exactly what the team needed to strengthen their roster and contribute significantly to their 1998 championship run, ultimately solidifying their status as a dominant dynasty.

Scott Brosius, who had already spent seven seasons in the MLB, experienced his first full season with over 100 games played in 1995. During that season and the following year, he showcased impressive hitting performances. However, his numbers took a drastic downturn in 1997, with a notable decline in his wRC+ and a negative WAR rating according to FanGraphs.

Despite a disappointing performance in 1997 and doubts surrounding his future in baseball, Brian Cashman, the Yankees’ assistant general manager at the time, initially rejected the idea of acquiring Scott Brosius. Cashman was skeptical due to Scott Brosius’ underwhelming season, and even the player himself had doubts about continuing his career. However, a scout familiar with the California area assured Cashman that Brosius was capable of bouncing back and delivering solid numbers as a third baseman. Convinced by the scout’s assessment, Cashman presented the trade proposal to GM Bob Watson, who ultimately gave the green light to the deal.

Scott Brosius did wonders for the Yankees

Despite his previous struggles, Scott Brosius defied expectations and had a remarkable turnaround in 1998. Not only did he earn his first All-Star selection, but he also showcased consistent performance throughout the season. By the end of the year, Brosius ranked third among position players on the team in fWAR with an impressive 5.0. However, his most notable contributions were still on the horizon, poised to leave a lasting impact on the team.

Scott Brosius demonstrated his excellence during the ALDS and ALCS as the Yankees secured victories in both series, propelling them to the World Series showdown against the Padres. Although Game 1 was relatively uneventful for Brosius, he made a significant impact in Game 2. Going 3-for-5 at the plate, he contributed a crucial RBI in the first inning, helping the Yankees take a commanding 2-0 series lead.

Following a solid performance in the All-Star Game at Coors Field, where Scott Brosius contributed with a single, stolen base, and run scored in the ninth inning of the American League’s 13-8 triumph, the third baseman faced a rough patch. In his initial 26 games after the break, Scott Brosius struggled, batting .212 and managing only five extra-base hits. He found himself pressing and putting too much pressure on himself. However, a valuable conversation with Yankees bench coach Don Zimmer served as a reminder for Scott Brosius to rediscover the joy of playing the game. He realized that he had forgotten his own advice to have fun and enjoy the experience, prompting a shift in his approach.

As Scott Brosius embraced a more relaxed mindset, his performance on the field surged. He closed out the regular season on a hot streak, batting an impressive .329 in the final month. With a newfound sense of excitement, he eagerly entered his first-ever postseason.

Following a sluggish start in April, Scott Brosius found his stride as the temperature rose, delivering an impressive .328/.404/.539 batting line in May and June. His remarkable performance, combined with the Yankees’ dominant 61-20 first-half record, earned Scott Brosius a well-deserved spot on his first-ever All-Star team in 1998. Throughout the remainder of the season, he maintained his excellent form and ended up ranking third among position players on the team with a 5.0 fWAR. Yet, it was his unforgettable contributions in that season that would truly leave a lasting impact.

Scott Brosius becomes the Yankees’ golden boy in 1998

With an astounding 114 regular season wins under their belt, the Yankees entered the postseason as heavy favorites, poised to extend their remarkable season by effortlessly overpowering their October adversaries. And true to expectations, the journey began on a high note, with Scott Brosius stepping up and assuming a prominent role in the team’s quest for glory.

During the Yankees’ dominant sweep of the Texas Rangers in the AL Division Series, Scott Brosius played a pivotal role, notching four hits and driving in three runs. His standout performance included his first-ever postseason home run in Game 2, adding to the thrill of the postseason journey. Despite a momentary setback when falling behind the Cleveland Indians 2-1 in the AL Championship Series, with two crucial away games still to be played, the team’s unwavering confidence in their collective abilities kept spirits high. They remained steadfast in their belief in each other’s contributions, fueling their determination to overcome any obstacles.

Back in New York for Game 6, Scott Brosius played a pivotal role in securing the victory. In the third inning, with the Yankees already holding a 3-0 lead, he delivered a decisive blow with a three-run home run, effectively sealing the game’s outcome. The Yankees emerged triumphant with a final score of 9-5, advancing to the next stage of the postseason.

During the World Series, he displayed an unstoppable performance. The 32-year-old third baseman was on fire, boasting a remarkable batting average of .471 throughout the four-game sweep of the San Diego Padres. However, the most memorable highlight of his outstanding performance came in Game 3.

Returning to his roots on the West Coast, Scott Brosius took his position at the plate in Qualcomm Stadium, ready to make an impact. It was the seventh inning, and the Yankees were trailing 3-0. With great determination, he battled against Padres pitcher Sterling Hitchcock, refusing to give in. After a full count, Scott Brosius unleashed a powerful swing on the sixth pitch, sending the ball soaring deep into left field for a remarkable home run.

In the following inning, as the Yankees continued to trail 3-2, Scott Brosius confidently approached the plate with two runners on base and just one out. The formidable challenge came in the form of All-Star closer Trevor Hoffman on the mound. Undeterred, Brosius focused on the task at hand. On the fifth pitch delivered by Hoffman, Brosius connected with perfect timing, sending the ball soaring over the center field wall. The impact was immense as it propelled the Yankees into the lead. With a surge of excitement, Brosius rounded the bases, raising his fist in triumphant celebration.

The following day brought ultimate triumph for Scott Brosius and the Yankees, as they completed a remarkable sweep of the Padres with a resounding 3-0 victory. The accomplishment was met with unparalleled satisfaction and joy. Recognizing his exceptional contributions throughout the series, Scott Brosius was rightfully awarded the World Series MVP title, solidifying his place as a key figure in the team’s historic success.

His later Yankees career

Over the course of the next three seasons, Scott Brosius remained a valuable member of the Yankees, making three consecutive appearances in the World Series and securing two additional championship rings. However, as the 2001 season came to a close and free agency loomed, Scott Brosius contemplated the next chapter of his career. While he still possessed the ability to contribute to the field, his priorities had shifted. As a devoted father of three, he was no longer willing to uproot his family from their Oregon home or endure prolonged periods of separation. Thus, Brosius made the difficult decision to retire from professional baseball, prioritizing his cherished role as a family man.

During the 1999 season, his exceptional defensive skills were recognized with a well-deserved Gold Glove award. Following a slight dip in performance in the subsequent year, he rebounded strongly in 2001, contributing significantly with a 2.2 fWAR season. Notably, Scott Brosius continued to shine in the postseason, delivering memorable performances when his team needed them the most.

After retiring from professional baseball, Scott Brosius embraced the role of a dedicated stay-at-home father for a period. However, his passion for the game eventually drew him back to the diamond. Initially, he started coaching at the local level in Oregon, honing his skills and sharing his knowledge with aspiring players. Eventually, an opportunity arose for him to join a major league organization, and he found himself donning a big league uniform once again, this time as the third base coach for the Seattle Mariners.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.