Headache brews for Yankees as Netflix takes over Opening Day

SAN FRANCISCO — The 2026 MLB season officially begins Wednesday night at Oracle Park. The Yankees and Giants will meet under the lights for the first game of the year. But the real story heading into the evening has nothing to do with who takes the mound or who bats cleanup. It is about what Netflix has done to the broadcast.

For the first time in baseball history, a regular-season game will be streamed exclusively on Netflix. The Yankees season opener will not air on the YES Network. It will not be available on any regional broadcast for either team. If you want to see the first pitch of the 2026 season, you need a Netflix subscription.

That alone has frustrated plenty of diehard Yankees fans. But the streaming giant’s approach to the broadcast has added fuel to the fire. Netflix is treating its first MLB game less like a baseball broadcast and more like a variety show, stuffing the coverage with celebrities who have little connection to the sport.

Netflix loads broadcast with celebrities, not just baseball voices

The core broadcast team is solid. MLB Network’s Matt Vasgersian will handle play-by-play in the booth alongside former Yankees ace and Hall of Famer CC Sabathia and ex-Giants outfielder Hunter Pence. Lauren Shehadi will report from the field. That group makes sense for a Yankees game of this magnitude.

The studio desk carries serious weight, too. Emmy Award-winning broadcaster Elle Duncan will host pregame and postgame coverage alongside all-time home run king Barry Bonds, three-time NL MVP Albert Pujols and former Yankees first baseman Anthony Rizzo. Bonds returning to Oracle Park, where he launched so many of his 762 career home runs, gives the Yankees season opener real historical gravity.

Sabathia, whose No. 52 jersey will be retired by the Yankees on Sept. 26, finished his 19-year career with a 251-161 record, a 3.74 ERA and 3,093 strikeouts. Rizzo, who retired after the 2025 season with 303 career home runs, signed with NBC Sports to become a regular analyst for Sunday Night Baseball.

But Netflix did not stop with baseball people. The streamer announced a parade of celebrity guests that has left fans scratching their heads. New York Giants quarterback Jameis Winston, comedian Bert Kreischer, WWE Superstars Jey and Jimmy Uso and “Thing” from the Netflix hit series “Wednesday” have all been added to the broadcast in various roles. “Thing” will help with the ceremonial first pitch at Oracle Park.

Netflix Opening Night broadcast team and duties

Celebrity approach is drawing backlash from Yankees fans

Jameis Winston does have a minor baseball connection. He was a two-sport athlete at Florida State and the Texas Rangers selected him in the 15th round of the 2012 MLB Draft. But he never played professional baseball. He is a backup quarterback on the NFL’s New York Giants roster.

That is a thin connection to a game that marks the first live MLB broadcast in Netflix history. Yankees purists and baseball fans alike expected the streamer to bring in guests tied to the Yankees, the Giants or the sport itself. Instead, the broadcast is shaping up as a crossover event designed to pull in casual viewers at the expense of the core audience.

The backlash has been steady. Yankees fans on social media have called the additions tone-deaf, arguing that Netflix is trying to “Netflix-ify” the game and strip away the feel of a traditional baseball broadcast. Kreischer, known for his shirtless comedy routines, drew particular criticism from Yankees and Giants supporters. The Uso twins and “Thing” pushed the frustration further.

Netflix vice president of sports Brandon Riegg defended the strategy.

“All of the events feel unique, and it’s our job to elevate those elements to make them even brighter,” Riegg said. “I think when you do that event approach, our experience at least has been you’re pulling in all the existing fans, but really you end up recruiting a lot of people that wouldn’t normally or wouldn’t have otherwise engaged or watched it. I think that’s always a big win for the league, and it’s certainly a big win for us.”

Riegg also pointed to the limited commitment as a selling point for attracting top talent to the Yankees broadcast.

“I think what folks have seen us accomplish on the platform, and also knowing we’re only doing a couple of things over the year, I think it allows greater flexibility for some of the talent we’re approaching, so they don’t have to lock themselves into a really long schedule or a high volume of commitment,” Riegg said.

The money behind Netflix’s MLB gamble

Netflix is paying an average of $50 million per season for three years of MLB rights that include the Yankees opener. That deal, struck in November 2025 after ESPN opted out of its contract, covers Opening Night, the T-Mobile Home Run Derby and the Field of Dreams Game each season through 2028. NBC and Peacock picked up Sunday Night Baseball and the Wild Card Series as part of the same reshuffling.

“This is in with our event strategy. On Opening Night, there’s only one game, and it’s on Netflix. And then doing the Home Run Derby and Field of Dreams, we can capitalize on the renewed fandom and energy around baseball,” Riegg said.

Netflix also holds worldwide rights to the three events, including the Yankees opener. The platform previously streamed all 47 World Baseball Classic games in Japan and has secured U.S. rights to the 2027 and 2031 FIFA Women’s World Cup. MLB is unlikely to be concerned about fan complaints as long as the checks keep clearing.

Netflix’s pregame coverage begins at 7 p.m. ET, with first pitch scheduled for 8:05 p.m. The game will stream globally on Netflix in English, Spanish, Japanese, Korean and Portuguese. All subscription plans, including the $8 per month ad-supported tier, will carry the game.

For Yankees fans who just want to watch baseball, the hope is that Vasgersian, Sabathia and Pence keep the booth focused on the action between the lines. The celebrity guests are coming whether the Yankees faithful like it or not. The best case scenario is that the spectacle stays in the studio and the game itself gets the attention it deserves.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.