NEW YORK — Brian Cashman delivered a reality check Wednesday about the Yankees prospect timeline. The general manager slowed the rising excitement around shortstop George Lombard Jr., saying the 20-year-old still needs more development before he can help the Yankees in the Bronx.
Cashman spoke during a virtual press conference at the general managers meetings in Las Vegas. He praised Lombard’s potential but signaled that 2026 is not a likely debut year for the young shortstop.
“I wouldn’t think ’26 is on the horizon,” Cashman said. “Offensively, it looks like he needs more time.”
His comments cooled the growing belief that Lombard could step in during the Yankees shortstop shortage. Anthony Volpe had shoulder surgery and will not be ready for Opening Day. Jose Caballero is set to handle the position for now.
Yankees GM Cashman gives Lombard Jr. reality check
Lombard moved quickly through the Yankees system in 2025. He earned a spot in the All Star Futures Game and climbed to No. 25 on MLB Pipeline’s top 100 list. His jump from High A to Double A Somerset in May came after he dominated the Florida State League with a .329 average and a .495 on base percentage in only 24 games.
The prospect is the son of former major leaguer and current Tigers bench coach George Lombard Sr. His defense drew strong reviews from scouts. Baseball America named him the Yankees best defensive infielder. His .984 fielding percentage in 947 innings at shortstop backed that reputation.
“So he could be coming out strong as early as next year, or he might need some more time,” he said. “The game will tell us more than anything else. Defensively he’s ready to go, offensively it looks like he needs more time, and we’re looking to ride that time and those reps.[…] So we’ll see.”
The numbers supported Cashman’s view. Lombard’s bat cooled after his promotion to Double A. He hit .215 with a .337 on base percentage and a .358 slugging percentage in 108 games. His 124 strikeouts against Double A pitching raised questions about his readiness for higher levels.
Prospect’s ceiling remains tantalizing
Cashman did not rule out all hope for a 2026 arrival. He noted that some elite prospects break through quickly when their tools begin to click. He pointed to Spencer Jones as an example after Jones surged through several levels in 2025.
“Players that possess some high-ceiling talent, which Lombard has, once it comes altogether, it can come really fast,” Cashman said. “It’s just an avalanche of success of instant ready.”
The Yankees protected Lombard at the trade deadline. Cashman confirmed that several teams asked about him. The Yankees grouped him with Jones and pitcher Cam Schlittler as players they would not move as they rebuilt the major league roster.
Lombard’s full 2025 line showed both promise and growing pains. He hit .235/.367/.381 with nine home runs and 49 RBIs across High A and Double A. His 37 walks at one point led the entire Yankees organization. Through July he even had more walks than Aaron Judge.
Somerset struggles highlight development needs
The jump to Double A exposed the areas Lombard must refine. His batting average dropped sharply from his High A performance. He kept strong plate discipline and posted a 13.6 percent walk rate, but his contact quality fell off against improved pitching.
Yankees Double A manager Raul Dominguez praised Lombard’s attitude during the slump. He pointed out the prospect’s leadership and energy. Lombard showed defensive flexibility by playing second and third base in addition to shortstop. That helped the Yankees plan for his future role.
“The game will tell us more than anything else,” Cashman said about the development process.
Spring training offered signs of future potential. Lombard hit .462 with two home runs in limited at bats. He singled off Cy Young contender Zack Wheeler, drawing attention from Judge and manager Aaron Boone.
Yankees maintain patient approach
Cashman’s remarks matched the Yankees usual method for handling top prospects. The Yankees prefer long term development instead of rushing players into major roles. Even Volpe moved through every minor league level before earning his major league shot.
Cashman did not close the door on a 2026 appearance. His comparison to Jones showed the Yankees believe development can speed up when a player finds consistency. Jones had early struggles but turned his season around with a strong second half.
“I wouldn’t rule out some point in ’26 at the same time because you saw what happened with Spencer Jones last year,” Cashman said. “Once it starts coming together, there’s no stopping a lot of these guys unless somebody’s standing in front of them at the major league level.”
For the moment, the Yankees plan to rely on their established infield group. Volpe is under team control through 2028 and Caballero through 2029. Jazz Chisholm Jr. offers another option in the middle infield. Cashman said the club has not started extension talks with Chisholm.
Triple-A likely next stop
The most realistic path has Lombard opening the 2026 season at Triple A Scranton/Wilkes Barre. A strong performance there could push him into the Yankees plans. The Yankees will not rush a player they view as a major part of their future core.
Scouts from outside the Yankees have praised Lombard’s skills and makeup. A scout told NJ Advance Media in early 2025 that Lombard projects as “a better shortstop than Volpe” on defense. The scout also advised patience and said he was “at least a year away” at the time.
Cashman’s comments Wednesday lined up with that opinion. Lombard looks ready with the glove, but his offensive game needs more work. The Yankees want him fully prepared for the pressure that comes with playing shortstop in New York.
What do you think? Leave your comment below.
