Aaron Judge’s Yankees swing untold: Ghost, dugout chaos, Toronto manager’s curse

Follow Us

NEW YORK — The Yankees season was dangling by a thread, the energy inside Yankee Stadium tense and brittle, when Aaron Judge stepped into the box in the bottom of the fourth inning. Moments later, a ball ripped off his bat so fast it seemed to shake the air. It clanged off the left-field foul pole and tied the game at 6-6.

Judge’s three-run home run not only changed the score. It changed the entire feel of the series — and maybe his October reputation. The moment was so surreal that Judge himself credited an invisible hand for helping keep the ball fair.

“I never had one like that right at the foul pole,” Judge told FOX Sports’ Ken Rosenthal after the Yankees 9-6 victory. “Thankfully the ghost kinda took that one over and kept it fair for us. That was a nice one.”

The crowd of 47,000 roared as the ball nicked metal and caromed into the left-field seats. Fans pointed toward Monument Park, where the Stadium’s most storied names — Ruth, Gehrig, DiMaggio, Mantle — are immortalized. Maybe it was coincidence. Or maybe, as Judge joked, one of those ghosts helped turn the Yankees’ October back from the edge.

A defining swing and an impossible pitch

The pitch itself was nearly unhittable. Toronto reliever Louis Varland fired a 99.7 mph fastball that darted inside — a pitch designed to tie up even the league’s best hitters. Judge had already whiffed on a 100 mph heater moments earlier.

“He blew my doors off on the pitch before,” Judge admitted. “He’s got all the leverage. He’s probably in attack mode. You’ve gotta attack that head on.”

On the next pitch, Judge did the unthinkable. He kept his hands inside and crushed the ball 409 feet down the line. According to MLB researcher Andrew Simon, no player in the pitch-tracking era — since 2008 — had ever hit a home run off a pitch 99 mph or faster located that far inside.

It was also the fastest pitch Judge had ever turned into a homer in his career. Manager Aaron Boone said afterward he had only seen right-handed hitters like Edgar Martinez and Manny Ramirez pull off something similar.

“I don’t know,” Judge said when asked how he managed to hit it. “I get yelled at for swinging out of the zone, now I’m getting praise. It looked good to me.”

Chaos erupts in the Yankees dugout

As the ball struck the pole, the Yankees dugout exploded. Players who had been slouched moments earlier jumped to their feet. Some screamed. Others pointed in disbelief. A few hurled towels into the air.

The moment was captured perfectly on television — a mix of raw joy and relief that spilled into the field. Several teammates followed Judge’s trot around the bases by waving toward the stands, urging fans to get louder.

SI’s report described it as one of the most animated dugout reactions in recent Yankees memory. Aaron Boone could be seen leaning over the rail, craning his neck, and tilting his body as if willing the ball fair himself.

He later admitted to using “body English” from the dugout to guide the ball to the right side of the pole. When it struck metal, Boone exhaled hard, a grin spreading across his face.

“Maybe the ghosts helped a little,” Boone said.

The moment that rewrote Judge’s October story

For all his regular-season heroics, Judge had carried a postseason burden. Fans and media questioned whether he could deliver when it mattered most. His postseason numbers lagged far behind his MVP-caliber production in the summer.

That conversation ended Tuesday night.

Judge went 3-for-4 with four RBIs and three runs scored. He made a diving catch in right field to save a run, scored after an intentional walk, and even extended a rundown long enough for Cody Bellinger to advance and eventually score.

“It was a best-player-in-the-game performance,” Boone said.

Judge now sits at 11-for-22 with six RBIs and a 1.304 OPS across six playoff games — a complete reversal from the chatter that followed his strikeout with the bases loaded in Game 1.

The Yankees needed a leader, and their captain gave them a moment fans will remember as “The Aaron Judge Game.”

Toronto manager hopes for bad meatloaf curse

On the opposite side of the field, frustration brewed. T Blue Jays manager John Schneider had the best seat in the house for Judge’s heroics. He didn’t enjoy the view.

After the game, Schneider tipped his cap but couldn’t resist a jab. “Hopefully he gets a bad night’s sleep and has some bad food tonight or something like that,” he told reporters. “Give him credit, man, that was a ridiculous swing.”

The comment captured Toronto’s dilemma. What do you do with Aaron Judge? The Blue Jays hold a 2-1 series lead. But they watched their three-run advantage disappear on one swing. They saw the momentum shift completely.

Game 4 is Wednesday. The Jays face a decision. Do they pitch to Judge again? Should they?

Judge is now 11-for-22 in six postseason games this year. He has a 1.304 OPS. The home run was his first of these playoffs. He also has two doubles and six RBI.

Toronto had silenced Yankee bats for two straight games. Then, in a single swing, everything flipped.

A comeback that felt supernatural

The Yankees, trailing 6-1 earlier, seemed lifeless. Then Judge’s homer revived them, and Jazz Chisholm Jr. followed with a go-ahead solo blast in the fifth. The bullpen locked down 6⅔ scoreless innings to close out the 9-6 win.

But it was Judge’s shot that everyone kept talking about — not just because of what it did, but how it felt.

Boone admitted afterward that the dugout’s energy after the homer was unlike anything he’d seen all year. “You could feel it through the whole bench,” he said. “It was electric.”

Judge, meanwhile, was more humble. “We’ve got a lot of guys who can step up,” he said. “Tonight was just my turn.”

Ghosts, curses, and a swing that changed everything

By the end of the night, the mythmaking had already begun. Fans online dubbed it “The Ghost Game.” Others called it “The Foul Pole Miracle.”

The Blue Jays might have made a mistake when they started poking at Aaron Judge’s postseason record after Game 2. Their subtle jabs — about his strikeout with the bases loaded and the talk that he couldn’t rise to the occasion in October — didn’t just linger; they lit a fire.

By the time Judge stepped into the box in Game 3, it was clear that Toronto’s criticism had woken something up. What followed wasn’t just a home run, it was payback — a response from a captain who looked every bit like a man playing with purpose, pride, and revenge.

Whatever you call it, the moment was vintage October — drama, superstition, and defiance wrapped into one perfect swing.

As the Stadium buzzed and fans chanted his name, Judge lingered near the dugout steps, glancing back toward left field where the ball had struck the pole. Maybe he saw the flicker of light again. Maybe he just smiled.

Either way, the Yankees had their miracle — one touched, as Judge said, by “a ghost.”

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us