Aaron Judge wields greatest Yankees bat in three decades? Fans weigh in

When Aaron Judge burst onto the Major League Baseball scene in 2016, few could have predicted the astronomical impact he would have on the game, let alone the Yankees’ storied franchise. The towering outfielder, known for his prodigious power and undeniable charisma, has quickly ascended the ranks, prompting fans and analysts alike to ponder: Is Aaron Judge the greatest Yankees hitter of the past 30 years? This question sparked a lively debate on Reddit, with fans weighing in on Judge’s place in the pantheon of Yankee legends.

The case for Aaron Judge

Judge’s journey from a slow start in 2016 to a historic 2022 season has been nothing short of remarkable. After a promising rookie year in 2017, where he led the league in home runs and won the Rookie of the Year award, Aaron Judge established himself as a cornerstone of the Yankees’ lineup. His 62 home runs in 2022 shattered Roger Maris’ long-standing American League record and solidified his status as one of the premier power hitters in the game. Following this incredible season, Aaron Judge rejected a substantial 8-year, $230 million contract offer, betting on himself and securing a 9-year, $360 million deal, along with being named the Yankees captain in 2023.

Despite a toe injury that limited his appearances in 2023, Judge continued to dazzle with 37 home runs and 75 RBIs in just 60 games, maintaining a .311 batting average. As the 2024 season progresses, Judge’s form has been nothing short of spectacular, boasting 39 home runs and 99 RBIs at a .315 average, putting him on track for a potential Triple Crown and another MVP award. He’s also on track to possibly beat his own 62 home run record from 2022. But – Judge has never been close to a World Series, and that may impact his case for being the greatest Yankees hitter in three decades..

What does Reddit think?

The question of whether Aaron Judge is the best Yankees hitter in the last 30 years sparked a flood of comments on Reddit, with fans offering a wide range of opinions. User RollofDuctTape kicked off the discussion with a confident “Yes. What’s your next question OP?” echoing the sentiment of many who believe Judge’s achievements speak for themselves.

Is Judge best Yankee hitter in last 30 years?
byu/3rd-party-intervener inNYYankees

Others, like BigToeJ0e, emphasized the unique challenges Judge faces in today’s game: “In my opinion yes, he’s also doing this when league-wide offense is the worst it’s ever been.”

Comment
byu/3rd-party-intervener from discussion
inNYYankees

However, not everyone was ready to anoint Aaron Judge as the greatest. User MatzohBallsack pointed out the absence of a World Series ring in Judge’s resume: “Judge ain’t there yet. He needs a ring.”

The Reddit thread also acknowledged other great Yankees hitters who have graced the diamond over the past three decades. Alex Rodriguez, despite his controversies, was a dominant force, especially during his MVP seasons. Don Mattingly, with his sweet swing and impressive numbers, remains a beloved figure, particularly for his prime years in the mid-’80s. Mark Teixeira provided power and Gold Glove defense during his tenure. Derek Jeter, while not a traditional power hitter, was the heart and soul of the Yankees for two decades, delivering countless clutch moments. Gary Sheffield, Paul O’Neill, Bernie Williams, Tino Martinez, and Hideki Matsui each brought their unique talents to the Bronx, contributing to the Yankees’ success and adding depth to the lineup.

Some fans drew comparisons to past Yankees legends, such as mojo-6, who reminisced about Don Mattingly’s prime: “I’ve never been more in awe of a player than Mattingly in his prime – 84-87.” For these fans, Judge’s greatness is undeniable, but they still hold a special place for the heroes of their youth.

Comment
byu/3rd-party-intervener from discussion
inNYYankees

A recurring theme in the thread was the debate over comparing players from different eras. User herewego199209 argued that Judge’s achievements are even more impressive given the quality of today’s pitchers: “What Judge is doing against the talent he’s facing makes it so much more impressive.” On the other hand, DeGenZGZ countered with the importance of considering era-specific factors: “At the end of the day, you gotta compare players based on how they performed in their respective eras.”

The final verdict

As the debate unfolded, one thing became clear: Aaron Judge has cemented his place as one of the greatest hitters in Yankees history. His combination of power, consistency, and leadership has endeared him to fans and solidified his legacy. However, the question of whether he is the best Yankees hitter of the past 30 years remains open to interpretation.

The absence of a World Series ring, the comparison to past legends like Derek Jeter, Alex Rodriguez, and Don Mattingly, and the era-specific challenges all play a role in this complex discussion. As Stonewall30NY put it, “Judge is the best hitter in baseball since roided Barry Bonds. His career OPS is 14th best all time, his single season adjusted for era is comparable to roided Bonds.” This comment underscores the sheer magnitude of Judge’s achievements, placing him in a league of his own.

Ultimately, whether or not Aaron Judge is the greatest Yankees hitter in the last 30 years may depend on what he accomplishes in the remainder of his career. As he continues to chase records and strive for that elusive World Series title, one thing is certain: Aaron Judge’s story is far from over, and Yankees fans will be eagerly watching every step of the way. What do you think? Leave your comment below!