New York — New York Yankees reliever Luke Weaver gave a vivid description of life in visiting bullpens during a recent appearance on the Baseball Isn’t Boring YouTube channel. Speaking candidly, he described the experience in cities like Boston and Philadelphia as feeling like animals on display.
“That’s ruthless… You always say it’s like you’re like zoo animals. I mean, it’s a closure, and people are, you know, wanting balls and they’re wanting to yell at you and tell you stink and get you unmotivated. Then you got some good ones in there,” Weaver said during the interview.
Weaver was referring to the bullpen setups at Fenway Park and Citizens Bank Park. Both stadiums are known for keeping visiting relievers close to fans, often exposing them to heckling and rowdy behavior. His comments reflected the tough mental environment players face in some of the league’s loudest venues.
Veteran right-hander familiar with tough crowds
SL.com
Now 31, Weaver has pitched for several organizations and has seen many road environments. He joined the Yankees as a waiver claim in September 2023 and quickly became a mainstay in their bullpen.
This season, Weaver has appeared in 58 games. He owns a 3-4 record with a 3.97 ERA and a 1.07 WHIP, striking out 66 batters. Despite solid numbers overall, recent outings have raised concerns.
His honest take on the visiting bullpen atmosphere came just as questions about his future in New York began to grow louder.
Tough outing fuels uncertainty
Weaver hit a rough patch during Monday’s game against the Minnesota Twins. He gave up five earned runs and managed just one out in a 7-0 loss. It was one of his worst appearances of the year and marked his fourth outing in six games where he allowed at least one run.
“That was trash,” Weaver said afterward. He pointed to mechanical flaws and said his body felt out of sync during the appearance. “It felt like I was fighting myself,” he added.
It was a sharp contrast from his performance in August. That month, he posted a 1.23 ERA over 13 games and looked like a key piece in the Yankees’ postseason bullpen plan.
Manager Aaron Boone, however, expressed confidence in Weaver, saying he had no major concerns about the reliever’s readiness for October.
Free agent value could price him out
Weaver’s contract situation is starting to become a focal point. After signing a $2.5 million deal last November, his performance has boosted his value. Industry projections now suggest he could command a two-year, $21 million deal in free agency.
The Athletic’s Jim Bowden noted, “Weaver will be one of the best high-leverage set-up relievers on the free-agent market. He has a 2.68 ERA and 0.80 WHIP in 45 appearances. Batters are hitting .151 against his four-seamer and .140 against his changeup. He ranks in the 95th percentile in xERA and the 99th percentile in xBA.”
Such figures would make him one of the most sought-after bullpen arms on the market.
FanSided recently included Weaver in its list of top 10 players likely to leave their current teams by 2026.
From waiver wire to Yankee success
Weaver’s rise with the Yankees has been one of the team’s success stories. After struggling as a starter across five organizations, he was picked up off waivers from the Mariners in late 2023.
In 2024, he posted a 2.89 ERA with 103 strikeouts over 84 innings. He eventually took over the closer role in September, converting all four save opportunities that month.
— Team USA Olympics Updates and Coverage (@TeamUSAOLYCov) September 13, 2025
During the Yankees’ postseason run, Weaver played in 12 of the team’s 14 games. He logged a 1.76 ERA and picked up four saves, including several multi-inning efforts that showcased his durability.
His impact helped the Yankees reach the World Series and put him on the map as a premier reliever.
Bullpen depth could face shakeup
AP Photo/Tony Gutierrez
As the Yankees prepare for 2026, bullpen depth remains a concern. Devin Williams is expected to test free agency after an uneven season, and Weaver’s return is not guaranteed.
The team has already invested in David Bednar, possibly limiting how much more they can commit to relievers. If Weaver seeks a deal close to $10.5 million annually, it could be too much for the Yankees to afford.
Weaver’s performance and mindset have been praised by coaches and teammates. His ability to pitch in hostile environments and high-leverage situations has made him one of the Yankees’ most trusted arms.
But the business side of baseball looms large.
Honest approach defines Weaver’s journey
Throughout his time in New York, Weaver has been known for his blunt and transparent style. His recent comments about fan behavior in opposing stadiums reflect that no-nonsense attitude.
That same honesty was evident after his rough outing against the Twins. He didn’t offer excuses and took full responsibility for his poor showing.
Weaver’s evolution from a struggling starter to a playoff-tested reliever has made him a valuable asset. But as the season winds down, his comments about being treated like a zoo animal may reflect more than just bullpen life. He, too, is on display. And the next few weeks could decide whether he remains in the Bronx or moves on.
Weaver has made it clear he’s willing to embrace the noise. The question now is whether the Yankees will be willing to pay to keep him.
