NEW YORK — Giancarlo Stanton delivered a resounding answer to his critics Tuesday night with a dominant four-hit performance that powered the New York Yankees to a 9-1 victory over the Minnesota Twins at Yankee Stadium.
The 35-year-old slugger went 4-for-5, crushing a towering 447-foot home run in the fifth inning while recording his first four-hit game since August 24, 2023. The explosive offensive display came just days after former Twins third baseman Trevor Plouffe questioned Stanton’s Hall of Fame credentials on his podcast.
“If you go over the numbers, it seems like he might be on the outside looking in,” Plouffe said on Tuesday’s “Baseball Today” podcast. “A .912 OPS, 4.7 WAR per season, those aren’t Hall of Fame type numbers. I want him in the Hall of Fame, but I don’t think he gets voted in.”
Whether Stanton heard those comments or not, his performance against Plouffe’s former team sent a clear message. The Yankees designated hitter looked locked in at the plate, showcasing the refined approach that has made his age-35 season one of his finest in pinstripes.
Yankees slugger posts career-best numbers despite late start
Despite missing the first two months of the season due to tennis elbow in both arms, Stanton has been nothing short of spectacular since returning in mid-June. His 164 wRC+ would surpass the 158 he posted during his 2017 National League MVP season with the Miami Marlins.
“Ever since he’s come back, he’s been dialed in,” Yankees captain Aaron Judge said.
The key to Stanton’s resurgence lies in a fundamental swing adjustment that has dramatically improved his launch angle and fly-ball rate. Throughout his career, the slugger’s high ground-ball rate has been a source of frustration for a player with his immense power.
“Better things happen when I get it in the air,” Stanton said.
The numbers support his philosophy. Stanton currently has the highest average launch angle and fly-ball rate of his career in 2025. His attack angle has improved from 8 degrees in 2023 to 11 degrees this season, while his ideal attack angle percentage sits at 63.9 percent entering Tuesday’s game.
Manager praises Stanton’s big boost
Yankees manager Aaron Boone has been impressed with more than just Stanton’s power numbers. The veteran’s plate discipline has reached elite levels, with his chase rate dropping 5.9 percentage points while his walk rate climbs above 10 percent for the first time since 2022.
“I think it’s just the quality of the at-bat,” Boone said. “He’s controlling the strike zone, I feel like, as good as I’ve seen him. He’s going up there with a good plan, and when he’s getting the pitch he’s looking for, he’s doing damage with it.”
That improved approach has resulted in a .376 on-base percentage, which would mark Stanton’s highest mark as a Yankee. Among all hitters with at least 150 plate appearances this season, his .962 OPS ranks fifth in MLB behind Judge, Shohei Ohtani, Nick Kurtz and Ronald Acuña Jr.
Return to right field adds defensive value
The Yankees entered 2025 with no plans to play Stanton in right field, potentially ending his days as a position player. However, with Judge working back from a right flexor tendon strain, Stanton volunteered to test whether his body could handle the defensive responsibilities after years of lower-body injuries.
“He’s a leader,” Judge said. “This guy’s been one of the best in the game for quite a long time, and for him to come in and start the season, they kind of tell him just focus on hitting and just focus on coming back. It just speaks volumes to the leadership.”
So far, the experiment has worked. Stanton has held up well in right field, giving Boone another lineup option as the Yankees fight for the American League’s third wild-card spot. The manager even suggested Stanton could see action in right field during this weekend’s series in St. Louis, despite the larger dimensions at Busch Stadium.
Hall of Fame debate continues amid stellar play
While Plouffe remains skeptical about Stanton’s Cooperstown chances, the former Twins player did acknowledge that reaching 500 career home runs could change the narrative.
“I think yes, 500 homers automatically puts you in there, especially if you’re not suspected of PEDs,” Plouffe said. “But, I know that’s kind of not how it works, and I don’t think he’s going to get voted in.”
With 441 career home runs already in the books and his current torrid pace, Stanton appears well-positioned to reach that milestone. His five All-Star selections, NL MVP award, two Silver Slugger awards and two Hank Aaron awards already form a solid foundation for a Hall of Fame case.
For now, Stanton seems focused on helping the Yankees secure their playoff position. His otherworldly power to all fields makes him perhaps the most dangerous hitter in baseball when he elevates the ball, as Tuesday’s performance against Minnesota clearly demonstrated.
The timing of his four-hit explosion, coming so soon after Plouffe’s comments, only adds to the narrative. Whether coincidence or motivation, Stanton’s bat continues to do the talking as October approaches.
What do you think?
