TAMPA — Big talk dies fast in the Bronx. It usually expires somewhere between a strikeout in the seventh inning and the back page the next morning. But when Jazz Chisholm Jr. opens his mouth, people lean in.
The New York Yankees second baseman is entering the most important season of his career. He is 28 years old. He is one year from free agency. He earned $10.2 million in arbitration this winter. And he just told the world he plans to become only the second player in MLB history to hit 50 home runs and steal 50 bases in the same season.
That is not a typo. Chisholm is not aiming for 40-40. He is skipping that milestone entirely.
Chisholm’s 30-30 season built the foundation for bolder targets
The confidence is not baseless. Chisholm put together the best season of his career in 2025. He slashed .242/.332/.481 with 31 home runs, 80 RBIs and 31 stolen bases in just 130 games. He earned his second All-Star selection. He won his first Silver Slugger Award. He posted a career-high 4.2 bWAR. He became only the third Yankee in franchise history to join the 30-30 club, alongside Bobby Bonds in 1975 and Alfonso Soriano in 2002 and 2003.
An oblique strain cost him a month. He played through a leg injury for a 39-game stretch in which he attempted only two steals. If Chisholm had played a full 155-game season, the floor was likely 35 home runs and 40 stolen bases.
That track record is what makes his latest proclamation more than just spring training chatter. The Athletic’s Chris Kirschner reported this week that Chisholm’s goals for 2026 include joining the 50-50 club, winning the AL MVP, earning a Gold Glove, another Silver Slugger and helping the Yankees win a World Series.
‘You’re looking at the second one’
When Kirschner reminded Chisholm that only Shohei Ohtani has ever achieved a 50-50 season, the Yankees infielder did not flinch.
“You’re looking at the second one,” Chisholm said.
He went further. “Ask Cap (Aaron Judge),” Chisholm said. “Real life. Let’s just be realistic. I got all the tools for it. I have the speed, the power, the plate discipline, the eye at the plate, defense. I got everything to accumulate a 10-WAR season.”
That 10-WAR target is historically rare territory. Only 60 times has a position player reached 10.0 bWAR in a single season. Among active players, only Aaron Judge, Mike Trout, and Mookie Betts have done it. Chisholm’s career-high is 4.2. His total career bWAR across six MLB seasons is 12.3. Reaching 10 in a single year would require 81 percent of his entire career output.
Chisholm also believes the new ABS challenge system will work in his favor. The Yankees found that out of everyone on the roster, Chisholm has the most incorrectly called strikes against him at the top of the zone. “I’d probably have 90 to 100 walks a season” if every call were correct, he told Kirschner. His career high in walks is 58, set last season.
Contract year pressure meets Chisholm’s desire to stay in pinstripes
This is not just about stat lines. It is about money. Chisholm can become a free agent after the 2026 season. No extension talks have taken place with the Yankees, per Kirschner’s reporting. The team typically lets players establish their market value on the open market.
But Chisholm has made his preference clear.
“I think anybody would want to be here for the rest of their career,” he said. “I haven’t heard anything yet. I left that all in my team’s hands. I’m just playing baseball.”
His name surfaced in trade rumors throughout the winter. Reports indicated that GM Brian Cashman was listening to offers. Chisholm brushed that off.
“I was in trade rumors every day over there,” he said about his time with the Marlins. “I feel like it’s just a thing with business. Is a trade going to be realistic? Not really.”
The Yankees turned away trade interest and kept Chisholm as part of their push for another deep playoff run. A season anywhere near his stated goals would position him for a massive payday next winter.
Boone refuses to put a ceiling on Chisholm’s potential
Yankees manager Aaron Boone is not dismissing the bold talk. He is not entirely endorsing it either. But he made one thing clear: he is not betting against Chisholm.
“We’ll be in a good spot if he does,” Boone said. “It’s hard to put a ceiling on him. He went 30-30 last year and missed a month, and didn’t run for two months.”
Boone added that he senses Chisholm is in the right headspace for a breakout. “He’s incredibly confident, and for good reason,” Boone said. “The bottom line is, if he goes out there and does his thing, and hopefully keeps even improving in this game, he’s going to put himself in a really good position come the end of the season.”
Judge, too, has noticed the growth.
“He’s just a complete athlete,” Judge said. “He’s a guy that can dictate a game with one swing or even one play on defense.”
A healthy season probably lands Chisholm around 35 home runs and 40 steals without extraordinary luck. The 50-50 club? That requires something closer to magic. But this is a player who credits Judge with pushing his development, who got engaged over Christmas in Finland, who told reporters he has never felt more prepared for a season, and who seems unafraid of the weight a contract year carries in the Bronx.
“Every year, I just want to win MVP,” Chisholm said. “The money, the contracts, none of that really means anything if I don’t win MVP. In my head, I can make as much money as I want. But if I don’t have the MVP, I’m not going to be satisfied.”
Whether Jazz Chisholm Jr. reaches 50-50 or falls short at 35-40, the answer to the question facing his season is the same one that faces every contract-year player: health. He has played more than 140 games just once in six MLB seasons. If the body holds, the talent is real. If the body breaks, the goals become footnotes.
The Yankees open the regular season March 25 against the Giants. Chisholm’s audition for superstar money starts now.
What do you think? Leave your comments below.
