Insiders fret over Juan Soto’s uncertain Yankees future as slugger settles into pinstripes

Yankees' Juan Soto rounds after hitting a home run against the Cleveland Guardians in New York on August 22, 2024.
X-NYY
Michael Bennington
Thursday August 22, 2024

Table of Contents

During his last spring training with the Yankees, Reggie Jackson, with his trademark humor, acknowledged that not everyone can thrive under the intense pressure of New York. However, Juan Soto‘s performance seems potent enough to buck the trend.

Juan Soto has displayed this ability since arriving with the Yankees. He has embraced the high expectations of playing in New York and has shown he is flourishing in this environment.

The synergy between Juan Soto and Aaron Judge is not about competing for the spotlight but rather about enhancing each other’s performance. They appear to elevate one another’s game consistently, from day to day and month to month.

Among the 41,263 fans at Yankee Stadium for the Yankees‘ commanding 8-1 win over the Guardians, Juan Soto and Judge combined for eight RBIs—five from Soto and three from Judge. Soto hit a two-run homer, bringing his season total to 36, and drove in five runs overall. Judge, who leads the major league home run race, added two homers to reach 45 for the season.

After the game, Juan Soto emphasized their collective dedication to team success. He highlighted his contributions, including a two-run home run and a crucial bases-clearing double down the third-base line, which ended the Yankees’ three-game losing streak and moved them ahead of the Orioles in the standings.

The synergy between Juan Soto and Judge in the second and third batting positions poses a significant challenge for opposing pitchers and impacts their strategies.

Aaron Judge and Juan Soto celebrate after 9-1 win over the Rays on July 22, 2024, at Yankee Stadium.
NYY

Manager Aaron Boone also observed that Juan Soto and Judge’s mutual support and encouragement are crucial to their positive influence on the team.

While Judge’s stellar performances have become routine for Yankees fans, Juan Soto has navigated the added challenge of adapting to New York and establishing himself as a key player. His successful transition under pressure underscores his ability to excel in a high-stakes environment.

MLB insider Russell Dorsey, reporting from Yankee Stadium, highlighted the standout performances of Juan Soto in the Yankees’ 8-1 win over the Cleveland Guardians. However, on social media, Dorsey speculated about the future of the Judge-Juan Soto pair, suggesting that their powerful batting duo could remain a fixture in the Yankees’ lineup for years to come, but expressed anxiety over the uncertainty of this scenario following the lack of clarity if the slugger is going to stay in New York.

I sat at Yankee Stadium tonight and watched Aaron Judge and Juan Soto be absolute nightmares in the box. And the thought crossed my mind … these dudes could hit together for the next decade. The next thought …. what if they don’t? This offseason is going to be something,” he said.

Uncertainty over Juan Soto’s Yankees contract

The focus now shifts to the upcoming offseason, especially with Juan Soto nearing free agency. Dorsey hinted that Soto’s next contract could rival or surpass Shohei Ohtani’s recent record-breaking $700 million deal with the Dodgers.

Dorsey’s remarks highlight the significant decisions facing the Yankees this offseason, as they consider the potential of retaining Soto alongside Judge for the long term.

Yankees' star Juan Soto will become a free agent this offseason,
FOX

Juan Soto is poised to enter free agency with expectations of securing a major contract. While the Yankees may offer an extension, it’s widely anticipated that Soto’s agent, Scott Boras, will advise against accepting any such offer.

This scenario has generated considerable buzz in the baseball world, drawing parallels to Shohei Ohtani’s recent free agency. MLB insider Jon Heyman, speaking on the Blair and Barker podcast, suggested that the slugger could attract even greater interest and potentially secure a more lucrative deal than Ohtani’s.

Heyman emphasized the role of Juan Soto’s agent in shaping the outcome of negotiations and pointed out Soto’s youth. At 25, the outfielder is younger than most star free agents, which could offer teams several prime years.

Heyman projected Juan Soto’s contract could fall between $500 million and $600 million. While he noted that the average for a player of Soto’s caliber is about $520 million, he speculated that his deal could approach $600 million.

Comparing Juan Soto’s situation to Aaron Judge’s recent contract negotiations, Heyman noted that Judge secured $360 million with the Yankees but might have commanded over $400 million elsewhere. He suggested that although Judge may be considered a superior player, Soto’s younger age and non-homegrown status with the Yankees might influence the negotiation dynamics.

According to reports, Aaron Judge helped Juan Soto feel at home in New York, and this might be one of the reasons Soto has been shining with the Yankees.
Wendell Cruz-USA TODAY Sports

Meanwhile, Juan Soto, however, has made a smooth transition to the Yankees, consistently performing well since his arrival. He seamlessly complements Aaron Judge. The prevailing view is that a pairing of him and Judge would be unmatched, and if Juan Soto remains with the Yankees, it could signal a return to the team’s previous dominance.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

3 1 vote
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
John

Being a Yankees fan since 1976 boy would it be great to have Soto seen up to play in New York for the next decade plus, but you never know with Hal Steinbrenner he might be skiddish about adding anther huge contract . He’s got money coming off the books next year ans is going to have to ante up for Soto. The Yankees would have a dynamic duo unmatched since Ruth/ Gehrig. Let’s Go Yankees!!!!!!!!

1
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

Join the Pinstripes Nation!

Your Daily Dose of Yankees Magic Delivered to Your Inbox

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Don't Miss Any of the Latest Yankees News, Rumors, and Exclusive Offers!