Is Dominic Smith real cause of Yankees’ reluctance to re-sign Verdugo?

Alex Verdugo brought his celebrated “DAWG” mentality to the Yankees’ clubhouse throughout 2024. Yet as the 2025 season approaches, the energetic outfielder remains conspicuously unsigned. What’s particularly puzzling is that even the Yankees—currently navigating questions about Jasson Dominguez’s left-field readiness while managing several injury situations—haven’t pursued a reunion with their former starter.

This absence of interest has raised eyebrows throughout baseball, including from Yankees captain Aaron Judge, who told The New York Post, “He’s such a great player. He brings so much value and versatility to a team.”

What explains the Yankees’ apparent disinterest in Verdugo despite their outfield uncertainty? The answer likely centers on Dominic Smith, whose remarkable spring renaissance offers a compelling alternative that addresses multiple organizational needs. According to MLB.com’s Bryan Hoch, Smith now projects to claim a spot on the Yankees’ Opening Day roster.

Dominic Smith’s resurgence in the Bronx

Dominic Smith’s baseball journey reflects the unpredictable nature of professional careers. Originally selected in the first round by the New York Mets in 2013, Smith’s path has included stops with the Nationals, Cubs, Rays, Red Sox, and Reds. After struggling to establish lasting major league footing, Smith arrived in the Bronx on a January 2025 minor league deal—a transaction widely viewed as organizational depth rather than a significant acquisition.

However, Smith’s spring training performance has transformed perceptions dramatically. Showcasing a rejuvenated swing approach and positional flexibility, he’s presented a convincing case for meaningful playing time. His left-handed bat combined with defensive capabilities at both first base and outfield positions supplies manager Aaron Boone with valuable roster options. Boone acknowledged Smith’s contributions, noting, “Dom’s been swinging the bat really well. His versatility is something we’re excited about.”

Smith’s Grapefruit League statistics have commanded attention:

• Batting average: .333 (8-for-24)
• Home runs: 2
• RBIs: 10
• OPS: .874

His dual proficiency at first base and left field, coupled with his left-handed hitting approach, addresses multiple Yankees needs—particularly given their requirements for first base depth and designated hitter alternatives.

Manager Aaron Boone hasn’t hidden his appreciation for Smith’s contributions, reiterating, “Dom’s been swinging the bat really well. His versatility is something we’re excited about.”

Smith currently finds himself competing with Ben Rice for potential DH platoon opportunities, especially with Everson Pereira continuing his rehabilitation from Tommy John surgery. Smith’s multi-positional capabilities align perfectly with the Yankees’ evolving roster construction philosophy.

Here is a list of positions Smith has played in his MLB career so far.

How Smith’s rise prevented Verdugo’s return

When the Yankees acquired Alex Verdugo from the Boston Red Sox last winter, expectations centered on stabilizing their outfield while adding left-handed balance to their lineup. Unfortunately, Verdugo’s inconsistent offensive contributions undermined his overall 2024 value with a batting average of .233, an OPS+ of 83 (significantly below league average), and a career-low slugging percentage. While his defensive contributions remained valuable, his offensive regression became impossible to overlook.

Verdugo initially approached free agency seeking approximately four years and $60 million, but market response has substantially diminished his negotiating leverage. Industry observers increasingly believe he may need to accept a one-year “prove-it” contract to reestablish his credentials as an everyday outfielder.

Contrary to the above, Smith indicates potential for greater offensive production than Verdugo demonstrated last season. While Verdugo commands several million dollars annually, Smith represents a $740,000 investment—a fraction of Verdugo’s expected compensation.

Also, Smith offers Yankees defensive options at both first base and outfield, providing Boone with strategic alternatives, whereas Verdugo remains exclusively an outfielder. The Yankees have consistently emphasized financial discipline and positional versatility throughout their offseason decision-making process.

Smith a backup for Jasson Dominguez?

The Yankees face additional uncertainty regarding Jasson Dominguez, who continues recovering from a torn UCL that necessitated Tommy John surgery. While Dominguez figures prominently in the outfield plans, his injury history requires contingency planning.

At 29, Smith contributes veteran experience alongside coverage capabilities for left field—potentially facilitating Dominguez’s gradual reintegration into everyday responsibilities.

Earlier this spring, Boone emphasized Smith’s professional approach: “The guy has been a really good hitter throughout his career, a pro hitter.”

With Smith emerging as a legitimate depth option, the Yankees may perceive little urgency to reacquire Verdugo—particularly considering additional outfield alternatives could materialize as the season progresses.

Should Smith maintain his productive performance into the regular season, this decision will reflect positively on the Yankees’ front office judgment. However, if Dominguez encounters difficulties or injuries accumulate, Cashman has to feel the pinch.

Looking ahead: The Yankees’ strategic approach

As Opening Day approaches, the Yankees’ roster decisions face intense scrutiny. Smith’s unexpected resurgence represents an encouraging development, highlighting baseball’s inherent unpredictability and the significance of depth acquisitions.

With Dominic Smith demonstrating legitimate value, the Yankees believe they’ve identified their alternative outfield solution—without requiring multi-year commitments or substantial financial investment. As the season unfolds, he receives his opportunity to validate the Yankees’ assessment—while Verdugo awaits his next opportunity.

Ultimately, Smith provides the Yankees strategic flexibility, backing up Dominguez’s development without excessive pressure. This approach exemplifies the organization’s commitment to balancing veteran experience with emerging talent, creating the harmonious combination necessary for championship contention.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.