David Wells criticizes current Yankees for not caring about losing

Tuesday July 23, 2024

David Wells, former New York Yankees pitcher, didn’t hold back his opinions during Old-Timers’ Day at Yankee Stadium. Speaking candidly, Wells criticized the current Yankees’ mentality, suggesting that they lack the passion and discomfort associated with losing that characterized earlier teams.

During a discussion on WFAN with Brandon Tierney, the topic of the Yankees’ ongoing struggles was brought up. The team has suffered a 10-20 stretch since mid-June, raising concerns among fans and analysts alike. Tierney compared the current team’s attitude to the days under George Steinbrenner’s ownership, noting that losing felt significantly more impactful then. “It became very heavy. Losing was felt. Everybody was uncomfortable,” he remarked. Tierney then highlighted a stark difference: “When they lose now, nobody’s incredibly uncomfortable.”

Wells, who played under George Steinbrenner and subscribes to a more traditional view of the game, echoed this sentiment. “They’re not (uncomfortable),” Wells stated. “They’re getting paid so much money, so I don’t think they care, to be honest with you.”

Criticism has been directed at current manager Aaron Boone for being too lenient with his players. Boone’s approach, often defending players publicly after mistakes or lack of effort, contrasts sharply with the tougher, more demanding style of past managers. Wells reminisced about the 1998 season under manager Joe Torre. “We lost the first three or four games of the year, and Joe Torre was pissed. He came in and laid it on the line,” Wells recalled. “He called out everybody; Jeter, Bernie Williams, everyone. It resonated with us.”

The 1998 Yankees famously turned their season around, finishing with a 114-48 record and winning the World Series. Wells implied that the current team lacks that kind of drive and accountability.

Despite their recent slump, the Yankees hold a 60-42 record, just 1.5 games behind the Baltimore Orioles for first place in the AL East, and they lead the wild card race by 3.5 games. As the July 30 trade deadline approaches, general manager Brian Cashman has an opportunity to bolster the roster for a playoff push.

Wells, who enjoyed a successful 21-season career, including four with the Yankees, where he won a World Series and pitched a perfect game, believes this current squad lacks the fire of the teams he played on. His remarks have sparked discussions about the team’s leadership and whether Boone’s managerial style is conducive to cultivating a winning culture.