Aaron Boone’s wrongful tossing: Did his past records mislead the umpire to overreact?

Follow Us

On Tuesday, the plate umpire ejected Yankees manager Aaron Boone in a way that is overwhelmingly viewed as wrongful. TV images clearly pointed out a fan’s yelling as the most potent factor that misled the umpire to toss out the Yankees manager. However, with a record 34 ejections under his managerial belt, Aaron Boone’s track record could also played a part in causing umpire Hunter Wendelstedt to overreact and commit such an embarrassing situation.

This ejection marked Aaron Boone’s second of the season and the 35th since becoming the Yankees manager in 2017. This makes him the most ejected manager in Major League Baseball during that period. However, Wendelstedt tried to assure everyone that the track record played no role in his contentious decision.

“I think that’s a question a lot of fans and people think,” the ump said. “If you look up my ejections, you’ll see Bobby Cox multiple times. Ron Gardenhire and I a lot. People don’t realize that Ron Gardenhire is a stubborn German like me and after we might have a situation we’d like to have a cold beer and talk about it.

Aaron Boone’s ejection most contentious MLB decision

Yankees manager Aaron Boone remains livid over his ejection just five pitches into Monday’s 2-0 defeat to the Oakland Athletics. The controversial incident stemmed from a disputed call where A’s leadoff hitter Esteury Ruiz was seemingly hit by a pitch.

Following the questionable call, the Yankees manager adhered to umpire Hunter Wendelstedt’s instruction to remain silent. However, a disgruntled fan’s outburst moments later resulted in Boone’s immediate ejection. Clearly frustrated, Aaron Boone condemned the situation as “embarrassing” and an unnecessary setback for the game.

Aaron Boone later clarified his initial intention was to request a review of the play at first base involving Ruiz. Despite his assertive tone during the exchange, Wendelstedt stood firm on his initial call, which ultimately led to Boone’s ejection.

“It’s embarrassing,” he told. “It really is bad. It’s embarrassing. I was pretty fiery initially, just wanting to make my point with John at first,” Boone said. “’Hey, obviously he got hit.’ It was clear to me (Ruiz) took a swing at it, too. And then Hunter made his point firmly back, and that was it.”

Thanks to YES Network’s cameras, viewers witnessed the heated exchange between Yankees manager Aaron Boone and umpire Hunter Wendelstedt unfold in real time.

Following the controversial ejection just five pitches into the game, Aaron Boone stormed out of the dugout to confront Wendelstedt. Their fiery exchange lasted for about a minute. His frustration extended beyond Wendelstedt, as he exchanged words with first-base umpire Marvin Hudson as well. On his way back to the dugout, the skipper paused three times to vent his anger further.

Expressing bewilderment, Aaron Boone reiterated his compliance with Wendelstedt’s initial warning. He recounted the interaction, highlighting Wendelstedt’s assertive demeanor but failing to recall any major disagreement before his unexpected ejection.

“He came at me hard and I really didn’t have issue with him other than saying, ‘You can make that call too,’ to which he made his point of, ‘Hey, I’ve got to see this.’ And I said, ‘OK, good.’ I kind of gave him a thumbs up and stood down. I think everyone saw what happened.”

Aaron Boone concluded by implying the incident spoke for itself, leaving the final judgment on the situation to observers.

Umpire blames Aaron Boone to justify the wrongful decision

Wendelstedt acknowledged the manager’s claim about a fan shouting from the stands but insisted the disruptive behavior didn’t originate near Aaron Boone or the coaching staff.  However, he challenged Boone’s narrative regarding the fan’s role in the incident. The umpire hinted that the disruptive behavior likely originated from further back in the dugout, behind Aaron Boone’s position. Wendelstedt emphasized his responsibility as manager, encompassing the entire dugout’s conduct, not just his immediate surroundings.

“If you said you can see a fan yelling at me, he wasn’t the only one and it probably lines up with behind Boone and maybe that’s what Boonie heard,” the umpire said. “I was approaching Aaron Boone because of something that happened at the further end of the dugout, and as manager of the Yankees, he’s responsible for the entire dugout, not just his vicinity. And that’s just how I took it.”

Interestingly, Anthony Rizzo, playing first base at the time, didn’t hear any fan comments that could have triggered the ejection. He theorized that perhaps a previous warning from Wendelstedt made Aaron Boone extra sensitive to any comments coming from that direction.

Echoing Wendelstedt’s thoughts, pitcher Carlos Rodon believed a misunderstanding might have occurred. He suggested the culprit might have been a fan positioned behind Wendelstedt, whose remark ultimately led to Aaron Boone’s ejection. Despite support from both Rodon and Boone, Wendelstedt interpreted the manager’s actions as directed toward him.

Looking ahead, Wendelstedt emphasized moving on and focusing on the next game. He expressed his hope that Aaron Boone would enjoy his evening with family and that both teams could resume playing baseball without any lingering tension from the incident. The umpire acknowledged past controversies involving managers like Bobby Cox, Ron Gardenhire, and himself, but stressed that it was time to leave those behind.

Wendelstedt hoped for a fresh start, with both teams resuming play without any previous encounters influencing the game. But his decision to eject Aaron Boone continues to hog headlines as one that is influenced more by the past record than just a error on his part.

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Follow Us